Top 50 Design Patent Case #4 In re Blum

Top 50 Design Patent Cases #4 In re Blum The number four cited case in design patent prosecutions is In re Blum, 374 F.2d 904 (CCPA 1967). This case stands for two principles. First, broken lines may not be used to represent an immaterial or unimportant part of a claimed

Read More »

The New York Times – Gorham v. White

The New York Times – Gorham v. White The following article was published in The New York Times on November 30, 1872 after the United States Supreme Court decided the famous design patent case of Gorham v. White (2nd most cited case). It is worth reading. The Article UNITED STATES

Read More »

Top 50 Design Patent Cases #2 Gorham v. White

Top 50 Design Patent Cases #2 – Gorham v. White The number two cited case in design patent prosecutions is Gorham v. White 81 U.S. 511 (1871). Gorham is the first design patent case decided by the United States Supreme Court. It established two major principles. First, a design patent

Read More »

Ex Parte Quayle – Third Most Cited Case

Ex Parte Quayle – Third Most Cited Case The third most cited case in design patent prosecutions is Ex Parte Quayle, 25 USPQ 74 (1935).  This should not be surprising since the case is cited on the USPTO’s Office Action Summary form. But ignoring the form, Ex Parte Quayle still

Read More »