PTAB Regular Appeal Case Table

P/UProceedingApplicationAppellantDecision Date Decision Issues
P2022001767 29630863Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc.Affirmed3/13/2023Decision 
P2022003273 29657524Gavrieli Brands LLCReversed2/23/2023Decision 
P2022002990 29675989Spectrum Brands, Inc.Reversed2/22/2023Decision 
P2023000170 29634064Gary Clinton Et al.Reversed1/30/2023Decision 
P2022000998 29617566Sunpower CorporationReversed12/20/2022Decision 
P2022002540 29694603Skims Body, Inc.Reversed9/29/2022Decision 
P2021004856 29646459Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.Affirmed5/31/2022Decision 
P2022001119 29727062Emily Kociolek Et al.Affirmed3/18/2022Decision 
P2021005119 29619024Banana Bros, LLCReversed2/15/2022Decision 
P2021004492 29572751Apple Inc.Reversed2/11/2022Decision 
P2022000909 29701818Royal Consumer Products LLCAffirmed2/9/2022Decision 
P2021003216 29643557Google LLCReversed1/31/2022Decision 
P2021003228 29646659Google LLCReversed1/31/2022Decision 
P2021001061 29541246Novartis AgReversed1/26/2022Decision 
P2021001056 29541250Novartis AgReversed1/26/2022Decision 
P2020006017 29613064Google LLC.Reversed1/26/2022Decision 
P2021002405 29635785Waymo LLCReversed12/30/2021Decision 
P2021003386 29610630Spectrum Brands, Inc.Affirmed11/2/2021Decision 
P2021003381 29610688Spectrum Brands, Inc.Affirmed11/2/2021Decision 
P2021002349 29583590Apple Inc.Reversed11/1/2021Decision 
P2020005977 29589132Whirlpool CorporationReversed9/28/2021Decision 
P2020005569 29643549Google LLCAffirmed9/27/2021Decision 
P2021002247 29622516Adobe Inc.Reversed9/23/2021Decision 
P2020006118 29622524Adobe Inc.Reversed9/23/2021Decision 
P2021000492 29650404Google LLCReversed9/22/2021Decision 
P2020006528 29669052Wouldn't It Be Nice LLCReversed9/17/2021Decision 
P2021002684 29647045Fujifilm CorporationAffirmed9/2/2021Decision 
P2021002799 90014262Lerman Container Corporation (Patent Owner) Et al.Reversed9/1/2021Decision 
P2021000734 29602782Hunter Fan CompanyReversed8/30/2021Decision 
P2020005156 29600392Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc.Reversed8/24/2021Decision 
P2020005689 29645439Google LLCReversed8/20/2021Decision 
P2021001988 90013952David Zahner Zahner Design Group, Ltd. Et al.Affirmed8/19/2021Decision 
P2020004386 29568897Nippon Valqua Industries, Ltd.Reversed7/30/2021Decision 
P2020004349 29603428Visa International Service AssociationReversed7/30/2021Decision 
P2021001189 29606389Apple Inc.Reversed7/23/2021Decision 
P2020006030 29674302Ubii LLC.Affirmed7/15/2021Decision 
P2020003668 29602914Westfield Outdoor, Inc.Reversed5/26/2021Decision 
P2020002059 29580430Bruni Glass S.P.A.Reversed5/25/2021Decision 
P2020004304 29620392V.F. CorporationReversed4/26/2021Decision 
P2020003621 29567680Jaguar Land Rover LimitedReversed4/21/2021Decision 
P2021002735 29641286Hfa, Inc.Reversed4/15/2021Decision 
P2020005018 29608417Rb Distribution, Inc.Affirmed4/2/2021Decision 
P2020003029 29588192Vitajuwel GmbhAffirmed3/26/2021Decision 
P2020002696 29534721Dolby Laboratories Licensing CorporationAffirmed3/19/2021Decision 
P2020001447 35502286Weiss Umwelttechnik GmbhAffirmed3/16/2021Decision 
P2020002481 29572270Owens-Brockway Glass Container Inc.Reversed3/10/2021Decision 
P2019003772 29562030Tsakiris, Theodore Reversed3/2/2021Decision 
P2020002736 95001540Sealy Technology Llc(Owner) Et al.Denied3/1/2021Rehearing Decision 
P2020004337 29517508Lubrizol Advanced Materials, Inc.Reversed2/26/2021Decision 
P2021000087 90014234Shuting Zhang (Assignee) Et al.Reversed2/16/2021Decision 
P2020002963 29506140Gulfstream Aerospace CorporationReversed2/2/2021Decision 
P2020002181 29628779Hunter Fan CompanyReversed2/1/2021Decision 
P2020000643 29542722Kcura LLCReversed1/29/2021Decision 
P2019006933 29475613Jaguar Land Rover LimitedReversed1/27/2021Decision 
P2018001630 29502896Joseph AbadjianDenied1/15/2021Rehearing Decision 
P2020002201 29612225Hunter Fan CompanyReversed1/6/2021Decision 
P2020001087 29571787Visa International Service AssociationReversed1/1/2021Decision 
P2020003796 29581072Intuitive Surgical Operations, Inc.Reversed12/30/2020Decision 
P2020003805 29581073Intuitive Surgical Operations, Inc.Reversed12/30/2020Decision 
P2020004518 29608792Apple Inc.Reversed12/28/2020Decision 
P2020001167 29571137Nasdaq, Inc.Reversed12/14/2020Decision 
P2019006169 29470931Apple Inc.Reversed11/18/2020Decision 
P2020001209 29506623Sony CorporationReversed11/12/2020Decision 
P2020001664 29510320Intergraph CorporationReversed11/2/2020Decision 
P2019002498 35500407FLOS S.P.A.Reversed10/26/2020Decision 
P2019002407 35500409Flos S.P.A.Reversed10/21/2020Decision 
P2020001192 29589424Whirlpool CorporationReversed10/5/2020Decision 
P2020000777 29517500Lubrizol Advanced Materials, Inc.Reversed9/30/2020Decision 
P2020000171 29639835Colgate-Palmolive CompanyReversed9/29/2020Decision 
P2020002282 29361328Karl Reisig Et al.Reversed9/28/2020Decision 
P2019004024 29522223Intercontinental Great Brands LLCReversed7/30/2020Decision 
P2019004029 29503952Intercontinental Great Brands LLCReversed7/30/2020Decision 
P2019004375 29570334Bredemeier, Lori A. Et al.Reversed7/16/2020Decision 
P2019004511 29543707Honda Motor Co., Ltd.Reversed7/10/2020Decision 
P2019007012 29619971Bliss Hammocks Inc.Reversed7/7/2020Decision 
P2020002736 95001540Sealy Technology Llc (Owner) Et al.Affirmed7/1/2020Decision 
P2019006598 29361552Shawn FojtikReversed6/2/2020Decision 
P2018001630 29502896Joseph AbadjianAffirmed6/1/2020Decision 
P2018007626 29543700George Bucher Et al.Reversed5/26/2020Decision 
P2019004749 29572562Amazon Technologies, Inc.Reversed5/21/2020Decision 
P2019004293 29598496Eichler, Mark Joseph.Reversed5/1/2020Decision 
P2019004315 29531964Amazon Technologies, Inc.Reversed4/24/2020Decision 
P2019003505 29527945Hf Global, Inc.Affirmed4/1/2020Decision 
P2018007433 29580932Jay Sato Et al.Reversed3/31/2020Decision 
P2019001458 29515499Perez, Jose Reversed3/30/2020Decision 
P2019002084 29453864Jaewoong ChungReversed3/27/2020Decision 
P2019003730 29535082Piper, Neal Reversed3/27/2020Decision 
P2018007742 29430805Antonio ChioccioniReversed3/24/2020Decision 
P2019002406 29525529Paul W. AdamAffirmed3/20/2020Decision 
P2019001727 29534975Fong, Alena Rose. Et al.Reversed1/27/2020Decision 
P2018001761 29360842Michael O. English Et al.Reversed1/17/2020Decision 
P2019001591 29547573Salas, Luis F. Et al.Reversed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001552 29547568Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001551 29547564Salas, Luis F. Et al.Reversed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001554 29547570Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001553 29547569Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001590 29547571Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001589 29547563Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001579 29547553Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001550 29547561Salas, Luis F. Et al.Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2019001588 29547562Salas, Luis F. Affirmed1/3/2020Decision 
P2018005551 29408999Birgers, Christopher J. Reversed12/31/2019Decision 
P2018005678 29409740Birgers, Christopher J. Reversed12/31/2019Decision 
P2018003279 29453426Vittorio Bologna Affirmed12/27/2019Decision 
P2019000370 29509362Yasutomi, Hiroshi Affirmed12/19/2019Decision 
P2018001766 29443590Imran Chaudhri Reversed12/19/2019Decision 
P2019001875 29541104Apple Inc.Reversed12/18/2019Decision 
P2018001345 29495451Juan AlmajidAffirmed10/23/2019Decision 
P2019001548 29547557Salas, Luis F. Reversed10/1/2019Decision 
P2019001547 29547549Salas, Luis F. Reversed10/1/2019Decision 
P2019001578 29547546Salas, Luis F. Reversed10/1/2019Decision 
P2019001549 29547559Salas, Luis F. Reversed10/1/2019Decision 
P2019001546 29547547Salas, Luis F. Reversed10/1/2019Decision 
P2018006442 29497580Ahren Bonnema Reversed9/26/2019Decision 
P2018004712 29461783Danielle GizaReversed9/24/2019Decision 
P2019001776 29522397Mohageg, Mike Reversed9/20/2019Decision 
P2019001901 29494441Mariet, Robertus Christianus Elisabeth. Reversed9/19/2019Decision 
P2019001900 29461780Giza, Danielle Reversed9/17/2019Decision 
P2019004306 95002100D517789 Reversed9/10/2019Decision 
P2019004157 29538604Niklas Vestling Affirmed9/6/2019Decision 
P2018003420 95001549D622531 Denied3/29/2019Rehearing Decision 
P2018004259 95001535D622088 Denied3/28/2019Rehearing Decision 
P2018004259 95001535D622088 Inter partes reexam new ground of rejection8/28/2018Decision 
P2018003793 90013497D559197 Reversed7/2/2018Decision 
P2018003420 95001549D622531 Affirmed6/1/2018Decision 
P2017004757 14012735Matt AlirolAffirmed1/16/2018Decision 
P2016000765 10943433Richard E. Fulton Affirmed-in-Part8/21/2017Decision 
P2014001032 29275866Jennifer L. Sadler Reversed2/22/2017Decision 
P2013003740 29379528Joseph P. SchultzReversed6/30/2016Decision 
P2013003506 29361328Karl A. Reisig Affirmed with new ground of rejection6/14/2016Decision 
P2014002624 29283341Robert BallReversed4/18/2016Decision 
P2014001431 29336284Kathleen H. Witsil Reversed3/8/2016Decision 
P2014001433 29336290Kathleen H. Witsil Reversed3/8/2016Decision 
P2014001432 29336285Kathleen H. WitsilReversed3/8/2016Decision 
P2012012651 29370780Jiaolong ChenReversed8/31/2015Decision 
P2015004669 95001793D536,881 S Affirmed7/30/2015Decision 
P2014007985 95001549D622531 Reversed with new ground of rejection 3/31/2015Decision 
P2014005649 29373729Richard A. Carlow Denied9/12/2014Rehearing Decision 
P2014005760 29373730Richard A. Carlow Affirmed7/28/2014Decision 
P2014005649 29373729Richard A. Carlow Affirmed6/30/2014Decision 
P2011011390 11000849Geoff Smith Reversed3/31/2014Decision 
P2010002075 29237687Bartley K. Andre Reversed4/19/2012Decision 
P2010005623 29289864Christopher J. Terrels Reversed2/21/2012Decision 
P2010001119 29276899Lars RosaenReversed12/19/2011Decision 
P2010000696 29176577Robert J. Libman Reversed11/2/2011Decision 
P2009013647 29176106Jamie L. WheatReversed6/20/2011Decision 
P2010002291 29271282Peter M.H. HungReversed9/7/2010Decision 
P2009010416 29264402Jamie Chauss Reversed8/31/2010Decision 
P2010004965 90007640D498187 Reexam affirmed6/3/2010Decision 
P2009012678 29212644Paul Lacotta Reversed6/2/2010Decision 
P2010000272 29196576Allison M. Hart Reversed4/6/2010Decision 
P2009002973 95000034D467247 Denied3/22/2010Rehearing Decision 
P2009009601 29241338Aaron Charles CuetoReversed1/22/2010Decision 
P2009009310 29302817Robert Finch Kellermann Reversed10/22/2009Decision 
P2009009305 29302816Robert Finch Kellermann Reversed10/21/2009Decision 
P2009005005 29244885Troutman, Damon Oliver Casati. Reversed9/23/2009Decision 
P2009010408 29236287Stefano BettocchiReversed9/15/2009Decision 
P2009002192 10943433Richard E. Fulton Reversed7/31/2009Decision 
P2009002973 95000034D467247 Reversed7/30/2009Decision 
P2009010242 29192232Philip W. WyersReversed7/20/2009Decision 
P2008005555 29226865Gordon E. VerweystReversed3/25/2009Decision 
P2008005613 29196598Robert T. Mitten Reversed2/26/2009Decision 
P2008002254 29222088Makoto Ishii Reversed11/26/2008Decision 
P2008002270 29174064Frank Howard SchallerReversed6/2/2008Decision 
P2007004521 29177452Scott M. Risdon Reversed1/29/2008Decision 
P2007001759 29206334Michael K. Kuehne Reversed7/11/2007Decision 
P2006000475 29158008Richard B. ManvilleReversed2/27/2006Decision 
P2005001466 90006515D437101 Affirmed11/30/2005Decision 
P2004001452 29138830William K. Stout Jr.Reversed8/31/2004Decision 
P2004001305 29138829William K. Stout Jr.Reversed8/27/2004Decision 
P2004000152 29149571Stefan Sagmeister Reversed3/15/2004Decision 
P2004000401 29160956Charles Pomeroy Reversed2/25/2004Decision 
P2003001862 29153657Stuart J. LedinghamReversed1/29/2004Decision 
P2003001760 29159145Arthur MillerReversed9/26/2003Decision 
P2003000656 29124773Richard A. CruzReversed3/27/2003Decision 
P2001000261 29066640NoneReversed2/27/2003Decision 
P2003000007 29092219DewaldReversed1/16/2003Decision 
P2002001818 29094432CounteeReversed1/16/2003Decision 
P2002002307 29105570BertieriReversed1/10/2003Decision 
P1999001013 29014141FrattarolaAffirmed1/3/2003Decision 
P2003000043 29065720James A. RiedlReversed11/26/2002Decision 
P2002002156 29113438Kemp Reversed11/19/2002Decision 
P2001000292 29076553KrunasReversed10/31/2002Decision 
P2001000961 8108133DukeReversed10/30/2002Decision 
P2000002150 29083483Mcgovern Reversed7/29/2002Decision 
P2002000494 29102729LincolnAffirmed6/27/2002Decision 
P2001002294 29097935Vittorio GrazioliReversed12/17/2001Decision 
P2001000337 29091083Golden Reversed8/29/2001Decision 
P2000002151 29099783NosellaReversed5/22/2001Decision 
P2001000467 29100490BertaniReversed5/11/2001Decision 
P2001000466 29112628RowanReversed4/26/2001Decision 
P2000002183 29082343GrantReversed4/23/2001Decision 
P1999001567 29035428HongAffirmed3/30/2001Decision 
P2000001905 29095094Saunders Reversed3/29/2001Decision 
P2000001221 29070030BonkoReversed2/27/2001Decision 
P1999001569 29021723BrunsAffirmed11/22/2000Decision 
P1995004961 29014077DavisReversed9/6/2000Decision 
P1999000356 29050057Taniguchi Affirmed8/23/2000Decision 
P2000000224 29081424SandersAffirmed7/28/2000Decision 
P2000001348 29092024CalfeeReversed7/26/2000Decision 
P2000000244 29069936SayersAffirmed7/17/2000Decision 
P2000000658 29084939Kennedy Reversed6/27/2000Decision 
P1999002009 29052870WhitsonAffirmed4/20/2000Decision 
P1998002173 29145835Stanley P. Frankoski Affirmed3/15/2000Decision 
P2000000543 29066640KlaymanAffirmed2/25/2000Decision 
P1999000410 29063883SchreiberAffirmed2/16/2000Decision 
P2000000553 29079653MeyerAffirmed2/3/2000Decision 
P1997001343 29039800Rodgers Reversed1/6/2000Decision 
P1999002020 29058031Haruna Affirmed12/20/1999Decision 
P1998000494 7954056GariboldiReversed9/20/1999Decision 
P1997003824 29042728CaswellReversed8/31/1999Decision 
P1999001010 29062011SourisAffirmed7/26/1999Decision 
P1999001024 29062504EckmannAffirmed6/30/1999Decision 
P1996002905 29008076GrinkusAffirmed6/23/1999Decision 
P1999000837 29074268MichaeliAffirmed6/21/1999Decision 
P1999001439 29033921JacksonAffirmed6/18/1999Decision 
P1999000838 29064666Sadlier Affirmed6/17/1999Decision 
P1999001028 29067859GrinbergAffirmed5/27/1999Decision 
P1999001018 29054175Strand Affirmed4/29/1999Decision 
P1999001568 29063397Kirn Affirmed4/27/1999Decision 
P1998002889 29022106GiamatiAffirmed3/31/1999Decision 
P1996000211 7929150FontaineReversed3/30/1999Decision 
P1997004065 29036355KurrekReversed3/5/1999Decision 
P1998001906 29045336StrougoAffirmed3/3/1999Decision 
P1999000065 29051335CastiglioneAffirmed2/26/1999Decision 
P1998002888 29044927Von Weissenfluh Affirmed1/20/1999Decision 
P1998003079 29052635CredleAffirmed12/30/1998Decision 
P1997001983 29038982Grinkus Denied10/23/1998Rehearing Decision 
P1997002893 29038948Genatossio Affirmed10/23/1998Decision 
P1998001689 7715259Regan Affirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001690 7715257Sheehan Affirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001693 7343182Herceg Affirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001694 7715261BrightAffirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001692 7715145Bright Affirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001897 7715144Bright Affirmed10/5/1998Decision 
P1998001691 7715262Williams Affirmed9/29/1998Decision 
P1998002937 29057491GalleosAffirmed9/23/1998Decision 
P1998000919 29042395Morse Affirmed9/17/1998Decision 
P1998002069 29052369GenatossioAffirmed8/26/1998Decision 
P1998002105 29052205LynchAffirmed8/25/1998Decision 
P1998001900 7715260Bright Affirmed7/29/1998Decision 
P1998000070 29019900RasmussenReversed7/28/1998Decision 
P1997003184 29048245Hutchins Reversed6/19/1998Decision 
P1997003183 29046917Hutchins Reversed6/16/1998Decision 
P1997002313 29024479GallegosReversed5/22/1998Decision 
P1998000068 29030090NagashimaReversed5/12/1998Decision 
P1996003648 7685563WolffReversed4/17/1998Decision 
P1998000064 29043747Kovach Reversed2/26/1998Decision 
P1997003411 29029284Decursu Reversed2/19/1998Decision 
P1996004010 29021122PearsonReversed2/19/1998Decision 
P1995003852 7855945FujisawaReversed2/17/1998Decision 
P1997002581 29031665Pedersen-RaskReversed12/3/1997Decision 
P1997002464 29038531Verdura Reversed10/23/1997Decision 
P1996003622 29019382CockramReversed10/22/1997Decision 
P1997002867 29012093HlavicskaReversed9/30/1997Decision 
P1997003204 29024652KachmarReversed9/29/1997Decision 
P1997002900 29039134HardyReversed9/26/1997Decision 
P1997002461 29020294FreyReversed9/11/1997Decision 
P1996003571 29021754BertoliniReversed9/11/1997Decision 
P1996003568 29009122LeightReversed9/4/1997Decision 
P1997002462 29031592DavidReversed8/29/1997Decision 
P1997002440 29036036ChavesReversed8/28/1997Decision 
P1996003210 29025638Schrank Reversed8/28/1997Decision 
P1997-1566 29033924SpiegelReversed8/26/1997Decision 
P1996-3643 29008022Davis Reversed8/20/1997Decision 
P1997-88 29015807FigueroaReversed8/8/1997Decision 
P1997-649 29031122Natuzzi Reversed7/31/1997Decision 
U2017-250929490118Ex Parte ScottReversed12/26/2018Decision112
U2023-17029634064Ex parte ClintonReversed2/1/2023Decision
U2017-141129495761Ex parte ChristophReversed12/26/2018Decision
U2023-18729638074Ex parte CarlsonReversed7/7/2023Decision
U2021-202129583860Ex parte BehlingReversed11/1/2021Decision
U2021-531829643316Ex Parte GrabowskiReversed11/9/2022Decision
U2022-77329573489Ex Parte ArmentReversed2/1/2023Decision
U2022-77229573484Ex Parte ArmentReversed2/1/2023Decision
U2021-484429629919Ex Parte BavelReversed4/1/2022Decision
U2016-707329421295Ex Parte NagaokaAffirmed9/26/2019Decision
U2022-17029640776Ex Parte PazminoReversed3/29/2023Decision
U2021-511429669331Ex Parte WoodReversed with new ground of rejection11/9/2022Decision
U2022-27629656012Ex Parte NorwoodAffirmed10/4/2022Decision
U2021-237929649584Ex Parte HabigReversed7/14/2022Decision
U2022-26329636636Ex Parte McRobertsReversed9/27/2022Decision
U2022-25829587366Ex Parte ChintisReversed4/4/2023Decision
U2021-543729599186Ex Parte BaldiReversed6/16/2022Decision
U2022-269929641898Ex Parte SakamotoReversed2/2/2023Decision
U2022-447929385792Ex Parte AkanaReversed12/23/2022Decision
U2021-536429555788Ex Parte SalpekerReversed1/3/2023Decision
U2021-539029646460Ex Parte PischkeReversed2/2/2023Decision
U2023-88629683223Ex Parte LeeReversed11/29/2023Decision
U2022-79129662821Ex Parte SartiniReversed12/30/2022Decision
U2022-78729713723Ex Parte WendlingReversed9/2/2022Decision
U2021-539329628143Ex Parte KaminerReversed3/22/2023Decision
U2023-23329688717Ex Parte PoindexterReversed6/29/2023Decision
U2022-352129617330Ex Parte DuBoisReversed2/28/2023Decision