Federal Circuit Case Table

Note: For decided cases (in red if opinion linked), the date is the opinion or judgment date. For open cases, the date is the filed date.

Date	Name	Number	Court	Origin	Status	Patent No(s)	Judge(s)	Opinion By	Issues and Results
2023/09/15	Columbia Sportswear N. Am., Inc. v. Seirus Innovative Access., Inc.,	21-2299	Fed Cir	District Court	Prec	D657,093 Heat Reflective Material	Prost, Reyna, Hughes	Prost	Scope of prior art in a design patent infringement analysis limited to type of article identified in the claim. Still unclear as to whether labelling a product with source identification or branding avoids infringement.
2023/06/30	LKQ Corp. v. GM Global Tech. Operations LLC	21-2348	Fed Cir	PTAB	En Banc Granted	D797,625 Vehicle Front Fender	Moore, Newman, Lourie, Dyk, Prost, Reyna, Taranto, Chen, Hughes, Stoll, Stark	Per Curiam	What is the test for obviousness of a design patent?
2023/06/09	Blue Gentian, LLC v. Tristar Products, Inc.	21-2316 21-2317	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D722,681 Expandable Hose D724,186 Expandable Hose Assembly	Prost, Chen, Stark	Prost	Judgment on inventorship counterclaim affirmed requiring addition of inventor because omitted inventor was significant contributor to patent claim
2023/01/20	LKQ Corporation v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC	22-1253	Fed Cir	PTAB	Non Prec En Banc Granted	D855,508 Vehicle Front Skid Bar	Lourie, Clevenger, Stark	Per Curiam	Whether PTAB erred in holding that LKQ Corporation had not shown by a preponderance of the evidence that D855,508 is unpatentable as anticipated or obvious under 35 U.S.C. §§ 102, 103.
2023/01/20	LKQ Corporation v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC	21-2348	Fed Cir	PTAB	Non Prec En Banc Granted	D797,625 Vehicle Front Fender	Lourie, Clevenger, Stark	Per Curiam	Whether PTAB erred in holding that LKQ Corporation had not shown by a preponderance of the evidence that D797,625 is unpatentable as anticipated or obvious under 35 U.S.C. §§ 102, 103.
2022/10/28	ABC Corporation I v. The Partnership and Unincorporated Associations	21-2150 21-2277 21-2355	Fed Cir	District Court	Prec	D737,723 Self Balancing Vehicle D738,256 Self Balancing Vehicle D784,195 Human Machine Interaction Vehicle D785,112 Human Machine Interaction Vehicle	Dyk, Taranto, Stoll	Taranto	Preliminary injunction against a non-party vacated where no notice, service of process, or an opportunity to be heard was provided. District court granted a preliminary injunction with a schedule A of defendants. The district court then granted plaintiff's motion to amend schedule A to include additional non-parties.
2022/10/28	ABC Corporation I v. The Partnership and Unincorporated Associations	22-1071	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D737,723 Self Balancing Vehicle D738,256 Self Balancing Vehicle D784,195 Human Machine Interaction Vehicle D785,112 Human Machine Interaction Vehicle	Dyk, Taranto, Stoll	Dyk	Preliminary injunction reversed because it was overbroad
2022/07/07	In re: Zahner Design Group, Ltd.	22-1026	Fed Cir	PTAB	Rule 36	D746,078 Shower Curtain	Newman, Lynn, Chen	Per Curiam	Whether a design patent application was entitled to the priority of a parent utility parent application. PTAB holding of no priority affirmed.
2022/06/22	Golden Eye Media USA, Inc. v. Trolley Bags UK Ltd.	21-2096	Fed Cir	District Court	Non Prec	D779,828 Foldable Bag	Lourie, Schall, Reyna	Lourie	Patent invalidity based on functionality and obviousness affirmed. Sport Dimension five factor test used for functionality. Rosen two part test used for obviousness.
2022/04/11	Sure Fit Home Products, LLC v. Maytex Mills, Inc.,	21-2048	Fed Cir	District Court	Rule 36	D668,091 Shower Curtain	Lourie, Reyna, Chen	Per Curiam	The district court's denial of a motion for preliminary injunction was affirmed by Rule 36 judgment
2022/02/10	Junker v. Medical Components, Inc.	21-1649	Fed Cir	District Court	Prec Pet for Writ filed	D450,839 Handle for Inducer Sheath	Dyk, Reyna, Stoll	Stoll	Patent held invalid under the section 102 on sale bar because a letter was a commercial offer for sale.
2021/10/04	In Re Surgisil, LLP	20-1940	Fed Cir	PTAB	Prec	Application Lip Implant	Moore, Newman, O'Malley	Moore	A design claim is limited to the identified article of manufacture. For prior art to anticipate the claim, it must come from a field of art analogous to the identified article of manufacture. PTAB's finding of anticipation reversed.
2021/06/21	AXTS, Inc. v. F-1 Firearms, LLC	21-1069	Fed Cir	District Court	Rule 36	D694,354 Firearm Charging Handle D705,384 Firearm Charging Handle D738,452 Firearm Charging Handle	Newman, O'Malley, Taranto	Per Curiam	Affirmed Mootness, Covenant Not To Sue
2021/04/21	Mojave Desert Holdings, LLC v. Crocs, Inc.,	20-1167	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Prec	D517,789 Footwear	Newman, Dyk, O'Malley D	Dyk, O'Malley Dissent	Motion Substitute Parties
2021/04/08	Boost Oxygen, LLC v. Oxygen Plus, Inc.	20-2268	Fed Cir	District Court	Rule 36	D610,250 Mask	Moore, Taranto, Chen		Oral Argument Cancelled, Contempt, Consent Judgment
2021/03/05	Bobcar Media, LLC v. Aardvark Event Logistics, Inc.	20-1847	Fed Cir	District Court	Rule 36	D652,353 Promotional Vehicle	Moore, Schall, Taranto	Per Curiam	Standing, Exclusive Licensee, Failure to Join Inventors
2021/02/18	Mojave Desert Holdings, LLC v. Crocs, Inc., N	20-1167	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Non Prec	D517,789 Footwear	Newman, Dyk, O'Malley	Per Curiam	Not Invalid A, Prior Art
2021/01/25	Tyger Manufacturing LLC v. Mike's Worldwide LLC	21-1567	Fed Cir	District Court	Rule 36	D761,487 Smoking Device	Newman, Reyna, Chen	Per Curiam	Exceptional Case, Attorney Fees
2020/12/11	Super-Sparkly Safety Stuff, LLC v. Skyline USA, Inc., N	20-1490	Fed Cir	District Court	Non Prec	D731,172 Rhinestone covered container for pepper spray cannister	Newman, Dyk, Reyna	Dyk	Not Infringed A, Oral Argument Cancelled, Infringement, Plainly Dissimilar
2020/10/06	Campbell Soup Company v. Gamon Plus, Inc.	21-1019 20-2344	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Prec	D621,645 Gravity Feed Dispenser Display D621,646 Gravity Feed Dispenser Display	Moore, Prost, Stoll	Moore	Invalid R, Obviousness, Commercial Success, Nexus
2020/08/26	Sealy Tech., LLC v. SSB Mfg. Co.	19-1872 19-1874	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Non Prec	D622,088 Mattress Design D622,531 Euro-Top Mattress Design	Prost, Reyna, Hughes	Prost	Invalid A
2020/08/05	Raffel Systems, LLC v. Man Wah Holdings Limited	20-2126	Fed Cir	PTAB PGR	Non Prec	D821,986 Switch	Reyna, Hughes, Stoll		Invalid A, Oral Argument Cancelled, On Sale Bar
2020/06/22	Ford Global Technologies, LLC v. New World International, Inc.	19-1746	Fed Cir	District Court SJ JT	Rule 36	D493,552 Vehicle Headlamp	Newman, O'Malley, Wallach	Per Curiam	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Infringement, Indefiniteness, Functionality, Patent Exhaustion, Notice
2020/05/14	Lanard Toys, Ltd. v. Dolgencorp LLC,	19-1781	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D671,167 Chalk Holder	Lourie, Mayer, Wallach	Lourie	Not Infringed A
2020/04/17	Spigen Korea Co. v. Ultraproof, Inc. 1,	2019-1435	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D771,607 Case for Electronic Device D775,620 Case for Electronic Device D776,648 Case for Electronic Device	Newman, Lourie, Reyna	Reyna	Not Invalid R
2020/03/16	Hafco Foundry & Mach. Co. v. GMS Mine Repair & Maint., Inc.	2018-1904	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D681,684 Rock Dust Blower	Newman, Chen, Stoll	Per Curiam Newman Concur in part, Dissent in Part	Infringed A
2020/01/15	Lego v. Zuru, Inc. 1, N	2019-2122	Fed Cir	DC PI	Non Prec	D688,328 Building Block from a Toy Building Set D641,053 Element of a Construction Set D614,707 Element for a Toy Construction Set	Wallach, Clevenger, Hughes	Clevenger	No Preliminary Injunction V
2019/11/13	Columbia Sportswear N. Am., Inc. v. Seirus Innovative Access., Inc.,	2018-1329	Fed Cir	DC SJ	Prec	D657,093 Heat Reflective Material	Lourie, Moore, Stoll	Lourie	Infringed? R, Logo
2019/09/26	Campbell Soup Co. v. Gamon Plus, Inc.	18-2029	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Prec	D621,645 Gravity Feed Dispenser Display D612,646 Gravity Feed Dispenser Display	Prost, Newman D, Moore	Moore, Newman Dissent	Invalid? R, Primary Reference
2019/09/18	Inspired Dev. Grp. LLC v. Inspired Prods. Grp. LLC	18-1616	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D524,559 Child Car Seat	Prost, Newman, Stoll	Prost	No Jurisdiction
2019/09/12	Curver Lux. SARL v. Home Expressions,, Inc.	18-2214	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D677,946 Pattern for a Chair	Chen, Hughes, Stoll	Chen	Not Infringed A, Title, Prosecution History Estoppel
2019/07/11	Auto. Body Parts Ass'n v. Ford Global Techs. LLC	18-1613	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D489,299 Exterior of Vehicle Hood D501,685 Vehicle Head Lamp	Hughes, Schall, Stoll	Stoll	Not Invalid A, Not Unenforceable, Exhaustion, Right of Repair
2019/07/02	Kolcraft Enters. v. Graco Children's Products	18-1259	Fed Cir	PTAB IPR	Prec	D604,970 Exposed Legs for a Play Yard D616,231 Exposed Legs for a Play Yard	Moore, Reyna, Chen	Reyna	Invalid A, Prior Art, Conception, Corroboration Inventor Testimony
2018/08/20	In re Maatita	17-2018	Fed Cir	PTAB Appeal	Prec	Application Shoe Bottom	Dyk, Reyna, Stoll	Dyk	Not Invalid R, 112, Definiteness, Enablement
2018/08/01	Advantek Mktg. v. Shanghai Walk-Long Tools Co.	17-1314	Fed Cir	District Court JP	Prec	D715,006 Gazebo	Newman, Clevenger, Chen	Newman	Infringed? R, No Prosecution History Estoppel, 12(c)
2017/10/06	Sacchetti v. United States	17-1484	Fed Cir	CC D	Prec	D382,264 Dual Telephone Base	Chen, Plager, Hughes	Per Curiam	Statute of Limitations
2017/06/08	New World Int'l,, Inc. v. Ford Global Techs. LLC	16-2097	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D489,299 Exterior of Vehicle Hood D501,685 Vehicle Head Lamp	Prost, Bryson, Wallach	Bryson	No Personal Jurisdiction A
2017/06/05	Evans v. Bldg. Materials Corp. of Am.	16-2427	Fed Cir	District Court OM	Prec	D575,509 Model Home Display and Carrying Case	Reyna, Linn, Taranto	Taranto	Arbitration Clause Not Applicable
2017/03/17	Nordock,, Inc. v. Sys.,, Inc.	14-1762	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	D579,754 Lip and Hinge Plate for a Dock Leveler	O'Malley, Reyna, Chen	Per Curiam	Article of Manufacture, Damages
2017/02/09	Chico's Fas,, Inc. v. Clair	16-1579	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D622,478 Combination Brassiere and Tank Top	Dyk, Clevenger, Hughes	Dyk	Inventorship
2017/02/07	Apple,, Inc. v. Samsung Elecs. Co.	14-1335	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	No Mention	Prost, O'Malley, Chen	Per Curiam	Article of Manufacture, Damages
2017/02/02	3form, Inc. v. Lumicor, Inc.	16-1535	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D621,068 Architectural Panel with Thatch Reed Design	Hughes, Schall, Stoll	Stoll	Invalid A, Obviousness
2016/04/19	Sport Dimension, Inc. v. Coleman Co.	15-1553	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D623,714 Personal Flotation Device	Moore, Hughes, Stoll	Stoll	Infringed? R, Claim Construction, Functionality, Expert
2016/03/03	Wallace v. Ideavillage Prods. Corp.	15-1077	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D485,990 Body Washing Brush	Newman, Dyk, Wallach	Newman	Not Infringed A, Pro Se, Plainly Dissimilar
2015/09/29	Nordock, Inc. v. Systems, Inc.	14-1762	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D579,754 Lip and Hinge Plate for a Dock Leveler	O'Malley, Reyna, Chen	O'Malley	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Damages R, Functionality,
2015/08/07	Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc.	14-1370	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D661,801 User Interface for a Surgical Instrument D661,802 User Interface for a Surgical Instrument D661,803 User Interface for a Surgical Instrument D661,804 User Interface for a Surgical Instrument	Lourie, Bryson, Chen	Chen	Not Invalid R, Not Infringed A, Functional, Plainly Dissimilar
2015/07/30	High Point Design LLC v. Buyer's Direct, Inc.	14-1464	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D598,183 Slipper	Dyk, Schall, Chen	Chen	Not Invalid R, Not Infringed A, Anticipation, High Level of Abstraction, Ornamental, Infringement, Commercial Embodiment, Additional Discovery, Amend Pleadings
2015/05/18	Apple, Inc. v. Samsung Elecs. Co.	14-1335	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D618,677 Electronic Device D593,087 Electronic Device D604,305 Graphical User Interface for a Display Screen or Portion Thereof	Prost, O'Malley, Chen	Prost	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Functional, Jury Instruction, Damages
2014/07/10	Anderson v. Kimberly-Clark Corp.	14-1117	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	D401,328 Absorbent Disposable, Undergarment	Prost, Clevenger, Chen	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Pro Se, 12(c), Plainly Dissimilar
2014/04/02	MRC Innovations, Inc. v. Hunter Mfg. LLP	13-1433	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D634,488 Football Jersey for a Dog D634,487 Baseball Jersey for a Dog	Radar, Prost, Chen	Prost	Invalid A, 103, Primary Reference, Secondary References, Secondary Considerations
2014/01/08	Pac. Coast Marine Windshields Ltd. v. Malibu Boats LLC	13-1199	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D555,070 Marine Windshield	Dyk, Meyer, Chen	Dyk	Infringed? R, No Prosecution History Estoppel
2013/11/18	Apple, Inc. v. Samsung Elecs. Co.	13-1129	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D618,677 Electronic Device D593,087 Electronic Device D604,305 Graphical User Interface for a Display Screen or Portion Thereof	Prost, O'Malley, Chen	Prost	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, No Permanent Injunction A
2013/09/11	High Point Design LLC v. Buyers Direct, Inc.	12-1455	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D598,183 Slipper	O'Malley, Schall, Wallach	Schall	Not Invalid R, 103, Functional
2013/03/26	In re Owens	12-1261	Fed Cir	PTAB Appeal	Prec	Application Bottle	Prost, Moore, Wallach	Prost	120, 112
2013/01/25	Hall v. Bed Bath & Beyond, Inc.	11-1165	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D596,439 Towel Tote	Newman, Lourie DIP, Linn	Newman, Lourie Dissent in part	Pleading Sufficiency, Individual Defendant
2012/11/27	Revision Military, Inc. v. Balboa Mfg. Co.	11-1628	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D537,098 Protective Goggles D620,039 Goggles	Newman, Clevenger, Linn	Newman	Infringed? R, Injunction Standard, Infringement Test
2012/05/14	Apple, Inc. v. Samsung Elecs. Co.	12-1105	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D593,087 Electronic Device D618,677 Electronic Device D504,889 Electronic Device	Bryson, Prost, O'Malley CIP DIP	Bryson, O'Malley Concur in part, Dissent in part	Denial of Preliminary Injunction Affirmed
2011/10/04	John Mezzalingua Assocs. v. ITC	10-1536	Fed Cir	ITC D	Prec	D440,539 Closed Compression-Type Coaxial Cable Connector	Bryson, Linn, Reyna	Bryson	Domestic Injury Requirement
2010/10/26	Colida v. Sony Ericsson Mobile Communs. (USA), Inc.	10-1374	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	No Mention	Linn, Dyk, Prost	Per Curiam	Frivolous Appeal
2010/05/04	Colida v. Panasonic Corp. of N. Am.	09-1582	Fed Cir	District Court	Non Prec	D321,184 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Radar, Dyk, Prost	Per Curiam	In Forma Pauperis
2010/03/09	Richardson v. Stanley Works, Inc.	09-1354	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D507,167 Multi Function Stud Climbing and Carpentry Tool	Lourie, Dyk, Kendall	Lourie	Not Infringed A, Claim Construction, Functional, Motion for Jury Trial
2010/02/24	Crocs, Inc. v. ITC	08-1596	Fed Cir	ITC D	Prec	D517,789 Footwear	Lourie, Radar, Prost	Radar	Infringed R, Claim Construction, Technical Prong
2009/12/17	Int'l Seaway Trading Corp. v. Walgreens Corp.	09-1237	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D529,263 Clog D545,032 Clog D545,033 Clog	Bryson, Clevenger DIP, Dyk	Dyk, Clevenger Dissent in part	Invalid? R, Anticipation, Obviousness, Ordinary Observer
2009/10/06	Colida v. Nokia, Inc.	09-1326	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	D318,050 Cellular Portable Telephone	Newman, Bryson, Linn	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Functionality, Dissimilarities exceed Similarities, Objectively Baseless, Anti-Filing Injunction
2009/06/03	Titan Tire Corp. v. Case New Holland, Inc.	08-1078	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D360,862 Tractor Tire	Newman, Plager, Gararsa	Plager	No Preliminary Injunction, Obviousness
2008/09/22	Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc.	06-1562	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D467,389 Nail Buffer	Michel, Newman, Archer, Mayer, Lourie, Radar, Schall, Bryson, Gajarsa, Linn, Dyk, Prost, Moore	Bryson	Not Infringed A, Ordinary Observer Test, Claim Construction
2007/09/12	Arminak & Assocs. v. Saint-Gobain Calmar, Inc.	06-1561	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D381,581 Sprayer Shroud D377,602 Sprayer Shroud	Michel, Gajarsa, Holderman	Holderman	Not Infringed A, Ordinary Observer, Pre EG
2007/08/29	Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc.	06-1562	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D467,389 Nail Buffer	Dyk, Archer, Moore	Moore	Not Infringed A, Ordinary Observer, Pre EG
2007/01/08	Amini Innovation Corp. v. Anthony Cal., Inc.	06-1096	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D488,936 Dresser with Mirror	Lourie, Radar, Schall	Schall	Infringed? R, Pre EG
2006/11/17	PHG Techs. LLC v. St. John Cos.	06-1169	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D496,405 Medical Label Sheet D503,197 Label Pattern for a Medical Label Sheet	Michel, Dyk, Prost	Prost	Invalid? R, No Preliminary Injunction, Functional
2006/05/31	Lawman Armor Corp. v. Winner Int'l LLC	05-1253	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D357,621 Sliding Hook Portion of a Vehicle Wheel Lock Assembly	Newman D, Radar D, Gajarsa D	Newman Dissent, Radar Dissent, Gajarsa Dissent	Denial of Rehearing En Banc, Point of Novelty
2006/03/03	Amini Innovation Corp. v. Anthony California, Inc.	05-1159	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D475,218 Bed Frame	Mayer, Radar, Dyk	Radar	Infringed? R, Pre EG
2006/02/22	Lawman Armor Corp. v. Winner Int'l LLC	05-1253	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D357,621 Sliding Hook Portion of a Vehicle Wheel Lock Assembly	Michel, Friedman, Dyk	Friedman	Not Infringed A, Pre EG
2005/08/24	Sunbeam Prods. v. Wing Shing Prods. (BVI Ltd.	04-1526	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D348,585 Coffee Maker	Radar, Bryson, Linn	Bryson	Inventorship
2005/07/25	Hartco Engg, Inc. v. Wang's Int'l, Inc.	04-1480	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	D401,194 Automobile Hitch Cover	Clevenger, Gajarsa, Prost	Prost
2005/03/09	Colida v. Sharp Elecs. Corp.	05-1061	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D321,347 Portable Handset Telephone	Michel, Newman, Gajarsa	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Frivolous Appeal
2005/02/08	Junker v. Eddings	04-1208	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D450,839 Handle for Introducer Sheath	Newman, Friedman, Bryson	Friedman	Infringed A, JMOL, Attorney Fees
2005/01/14	Fuji Photo Film Co. v. Jazz Photo Corp.	03-1324	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D345,750 Single Use Camera	Clevenger, Radar, Linn	Radar	Infringed A, Exhaustion, Right of Repair, Inducement, Reasonable Royalty, Willfulness, Enhanced Damages, Permanent Injunction
2005/01/07	Jore Corp. v. Kouvato, Inc.	04-1163	Fed Cir	District Court SJ JT	Non Prec	D419,575 Drill Bit	Lourie, Friedman, Bryson	Bryson	Invalid R, Obviousness
2005/01/04	Brooks Furniture Mfg. v. Dutailier Int'l, Inc.	03-1379	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D417,983 Rocking Chair Trim	Newman, Lourie, Dyk	Newman	Not Infringed A, Attorney Fees, Attorney Opinion, 285
2004/12/23	Anheuser-Busch Cos. v. Crown Cork & Seal Techs. Corp.	04-1185	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D387,987 End Closure for a Container	Mayer, Lourie, Dyk	Lourie
2004/12/02	Colida v. Sanyo N. Am. Corp.	04-1287	Fed Cir	District Court	Prec	D321,347 Portable Handset Telephone	Newman D, Michel, Prost	Order, Newman Dissent	Not Infringed A, Frivolous Appeal, Sanctions
2004/12/02	Colida v. Sanyo N. Am. Corp.	04-1287	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D321,347 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Newman, Michel, Prost	Newman	Not Infringed A, Ordinary Observer
2004/11/30	Kyocera Wireless Corp. v. President Elecs. Ltd.	04-1345	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D321,184 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Newman, Michel, Prost	Newman	Not Infringed A,
2004/11/03	Colida v. Matsushita Elec. Corp. of Am.	04-1348	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D321,347 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Clevenger, Gajarsa, Prost	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A,
2004/10/20	Bernhardt L.L.C. v. Collezione Europa USA, Inc.	04-1024	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D438,727 Buffet D439,763 Cabinet D439,770 Table D441,560 Bed D441,975 Chair D441,980 Bed	Mayer, Michel, Linn	Linn	Infringed? R, Point of Novelty, Public Use
2004/10/13	Collins v. Platts	04-1511	Fed Cir	District Court Perm I	Non Prec	?	Mayer, Michel, Clevenger	Clevenger	Permanent Injunction Vacated
2004/08/16	Fisher-Price, Inc. v. Safety st, Inc.	04-1644	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	D431,940 Children's Play Space	Michel, Schall, Prost	Schall	Not Invalid A, Not Infringed R, On Sale Bar, Point of Novelty
2004/04/23	A- Elecs., Inc. v. Chang	04-1162	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	?	Schall, Gajarsa, Prost	Schall	Dismissed, Premature Appeal
2004/03/02	Colida v. Ericsson, Inc.	03-1599	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D318,050 Cellular Portable Telephone	Michel, Bryson, Prost	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Point of Novelty, Sanctions
2004/02/12	Rocket Jewelry Box, Inc. v. Quality Int'l Packaging Ltd.	03-1307	Fed Cir	District Court FJAA	Non Prec	D333,264 Jewelry box	Michel, Schall, Prost	Prost	Arbitration Award, Permanent Injunction vacated
2004/01/16	Minka Lighting, Inc. v. Craftmade Int'l, Inc.	03-1162	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D380,539 Combined Ceiling Fan and Light	Michel, Radar, Dyk	Radar	Not Infringed A, Claim Construction, Doctrine of Equivalents
2003/11/18	Unique Functional Prods., Inc. v. Mastercraft Boat Co., Inc.	03-1157	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	D320,777 Trailer Coupler	Michel, Lourie, Dyk	Lourie	Not Infringed R, Claim Construction, Doctrine of Equivalents, Ordinary Observer, Preliminary Injunction Vacated
2003/10/08	Colida v. LG Elecs., Inc.	03-1399	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	D321,347 Cellular Portable Handset Telephone	Mayer, Micel, Bryson	Per Curiam	Personal Jurisdiction, Dismissal Affirmed, Service of Process
2003/05/01	Newspring Indus. Corp. v. Sun Gem Plastics Enter. Co.	02-1450	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	D439,159 Rectangular Stackable Container Including Triple Sealed Rim	Michel, Friedman, Linn	Linn	Not Infringed A, Claim Construction
2002/11/07	Golan v. Pingel Enter.	01-1626	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D363,533 Fuel Valve	Newman, Gajarsa, Prost	Gajarsa	Not Infringed A, Bad Faith Assertion
2002/09/24	Rosco, Inc. v. Mirror Lite Co.	01-1271	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D346,357 Automotive Mirror	Lourie, Plager, Dyk	Dyk	Not Invalid R, Functionality, Obviousness
2002/07/11	Bissell v. United States	5031-02-01 00:00:00	Fed Cir	FC OD	Non Prec	D308,008 Hose Clamp	Radar, Friedman, Gajarsa	Per Curiam	Federal Claims, Statute of Limitations
2002/06/28	Catalina Lighting v. Lamps Plus	01-1563	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D353,904 Combined Torchiere Lamp and Adjustable Accent Lights	Mayer, Bryson, Prost	Prost	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, JMOL, Damages
2002/04/16	Designs by Skaffles, Inc. v.ew L&N Sales & Mktg.	01-1264	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D292,030 Ornamental Hairband or Similar Article	Bryson, Gajarsa, Dyk	Gajarsa	Covenant not to Sue, License Agreement
2002/03/13	Contessa Food Prods. v. Conagra, Inc.	01-1157	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D404,612 Serving Tray with Shrimp	Clevenger, Schall, Linn	Linn	Infringed? R, Visible during normal use
2002/02/06	Avid Identification Sys. v. Global ID Sys.	00-1573	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D318,658 Identity Tag Reader	Michel, Clevenger, Gajarsa	Per Curiam	Damages, Deemed Admissions
2002/01/30	New L&N Sales & Mktg. v. Revson	01-1126	Fed Cir	District Court DJ	Non Prec	D292,030 Ornamental Hairband or Similar Article	Mayer, Lourie, Linn	Per Curiam	Standing to Appeal
2002/01/30	Hoop v. Hoop	01-1288	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D428,831 Pair of Motorcycle Fairing Edge Parts	Mayer, Lourie, Dyk	Mayer, Lourie Dissent	Inventorship, Substantial similarity
2001/08/21	Jazz Photo Corp. v. ITC	99-1431	Fed Cir	ITC	Prec	D345,750 Single Use Camera	Newman, Michel, Garjarsa	Newman	Patent Exhaustion
2001/07/10	Door-Master Corp. v. Yorktowne, Inc.	00-1526	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D338,718 Integrated Door and Frame	Radar, Gajarsa, Linn	Radar	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Willful Infringement, No Attorney Fees, JMOL, Functionality, Anticipation, Peters
2001/06/27	Precor, Inc. v. Life Fitness	00-1201	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	D313,826 Excercise Treadmill	Clevenger, Schall, Bryson	Schall	Not Infringed R, JMOL, Ornamental Features Only
2001/04/18	In re Haruna	00-1283	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Pre-recorded Optical Disc	Schall, Friedman, Gajarsa	Schall	Not Invalid R, Obviousness, Teaches Away, Color
2000/10/04	In re Chung	00-1148	Fed Cir	BPAI	Non Prec	Application Cigarette Packet	Bryson, Archer, Gajarsa	Per Curiam	Invalid A, Obviousness, Functionality
2000/04/10	Blankenship v. Barnett Bank N.A. N	00-1087	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	D336,780 Credit Card Wallet	Newman, Michel, Bryson	Newman	Pleading Requirements, Point of Novelty
1999/11/16	Ross v. Sonax Furniture Mfg. Ltd.	98-1297	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D327,381 Storage Shelving Unit	Bryson, Skelton, Gajarsa	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Substantially similar, Point of Novelty
1999/09/08	Seiko Epson Corp. v. Nu-Kote Int'l, Inc.	97-1313	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D351,190 Ink Cartridge	Newman, Plager, Bryson	Newman	Not Invalid R, Matter of Concern, Functionality
1999/08/31	Anthony John Antonious v. Spalding & Evenflo Companies, Inc.	98-1478	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D320,056 Iron Type Golf Club Head D327,308 Iron Type Gold Club Head	Mayer, Rich, Schall	Schall	Not Invalid R, Not Infringed A, Indefiniteness, Multiple Embodiments, Substantially Similar
1999/08/30	Berry Sterling Corp. v. Pescor Plastics, Inc.	98-1381	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Non Prec	D362,368 Container to Fit a Vehicle Cup Receptacle	Rich, Freidman, Schall	Schall	Invalid A, Obviousness, Corroboration, Secondary Considerations, Functionality
1999/02/11	Elk Corp. v. GAF Bldg. Materials Corp.	98-1369	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D344,144 Laminated Shingle	Michel, Plager, Radar	Plager	Unenforceable, Inequitable Conduct
1999/01/27	Sash Controls, Inc. v. Talon LLC	98-1152	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D340,398 Door Handle	Rich, Plager, Radar	Per Curiam	Invalid? R, Secondary Considerations, Obviousness, Terminal Disclaimer, Double Patenting, Analogous Art, Inequitable Conduct
1998/11/10	Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. Hercules Tire & Rubber Co.	97-1199	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D349,080 Tire Tread	Newman, Plager, Schall	Newman	Not Infringed A, Claim Construction, Colorable Imitation, Ordinary Observer, Inequitable Conduct
1998/09/18	Unidynamics Corp. v. Automatic Prods. Int'l	97-1322	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D307,446 Vending Machine for Foods	Rich, Michel, Schall	Rich	Infringed? R, Ordinary Observer Test, Inequitable Conduct, Functionality
1998/05/20	In re Daniels	97-1225	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Leecher	Newman, Lourie, Bryson	Newman	Not Invalid R, 120 Priority, Written Description
1998/03/31	Continental Plastic Containers v. Owens Brockway Plastic Products, Inc.	96-1509	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D352,905 Exterior Surface of a Sidewall for a Juice ContainerExterior Surface of a Sidewall for a Juice Container	Mayer, Rich, Newman CIP DIP	Rich, Newman Concur in part, Dissent in part	Invalid A, On Sale Bar, Public Use Bar, Useful
1998/03/12	Nike, Inc. v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.	97-1173	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D348,765 Shoe Upper	Mayer, Newman, Plager	Newman	Marking under 289
1998/02/24	Colida v. Sony Corp. of Am.	97-1563	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D321,184 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Mayer, Newman, Plager	Per Curiam	Res Judicata
1997/10/29	Scosche Indus. v. Visor Gear	97-1003	Fed Cir	Rehearing	Prec	D362,159 Compact Disc Holder Attachedable to a Vehicle Visor	Newman, Clevenger, Bryson	Per Curiam	Actual Controversy, Res Judicata
1997/10/20	American Eagle Wheel Corp. v. American Racing Equip., Inc.	97-1275	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	D361,461 Vehicle Wheel Front Face	Newman, Mayer, Clevenger	Per Curiam	Infringed A, Preliminary Injunction
1997/09/04	Hupp v. Siroflex of Am., Inc.	95-1268	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D342,528 Plastic Mold	Newman, Smith, Clevenger	Newman	Not Invalid R, Not Infringed A, Functionality, Anticipation, On Sale, Obviousness, Suggestion to Combine, Jury Instruction, Ambiguity, Substantial Similarity, Inequitable Conduct, Injunction Bond
1997/09/03	Berry Sterling Corp. v. Prescor Plastics, Inc.	96-1380	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D362,368 Container to Fit a Vehicle Cup Receptical	Rich, Clevenger, Bryson	Rich	Not Invalid R, Functionality
1997/08/11	Scosche Indus. v. Visor Gear	97-1003	Fed Cir	District Court JR68	Prec	D362,159 Compact Disc Holder Attachedable to a Vehicle Visor	Newman, Clevenger, Bryson	Bryson	Rule 68 Judgment, Unfair Competition, Bad Faith
1997/08/08	OddzOn Prods. v. Just Toys	96-1550	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D346,001 Tossing Ball	Michel, Lourie, Radar	Lourie	Not Invalid A, Not Infringed A, 102(f) prior art with 103, Obviousness, Claim Construction, Functionality, Factor Out
1997/05/01	Paramount Telecom v. Broadway Dep't Stores	96-1450	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D340,055 Telephone	Newman, Michel, Plager	Newman	Appeal Dismissed, No FInal Judgment, 1292(b)
1997/03/06	National Presto Indus. v. Dazey Corp.	96-1162	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec		Lourie, Skelton, Rader	Rader	Enforce Settlement Agreement
1996/11/18	Durling v. Spectrum Furniture Co.	96-1119	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D339,243 Combined Sectional Sofa with End Tables and Corner Table	Clevenger, Skelton, Rader	Clevenger	Not Invalid R, Primary Reference, Obviousness, Claim Construction
1996/08/29	Best Lock Corp. v. Ilco Unican Corp.	95-1528	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D327,636 Portion of a Key Blade Blank	Archer, Newman D, Lourie	Lourie, Newman Dissent	Invalid A, Functionality
1996/08/23	Swede Indus. v. Zebco Corp.	95-1256	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Non Prec	D307,621 Fishing Reel	Rich, Michel, Plager	Plager	Not Invalid A, Not InfringedCorrect Inventorship
1996/07/24	In re Borden	96-1057	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Twin Neck Dispensing Container	Rader, Skelton, Bryson	Bryson	Invalid A, Obviousness
1996/07/18	GAF Bldg. Materials Corp. v. Elk Corp.	95-1549	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D344,144 Laminated Shingle	Plager, Lourie, Bryson	Lourie	Actual Controversy, Subject Matter Jurisdiction
1996/06/07	In re Sharper Image Corp.	Misc. 464	Fed Cir	Mandamus	Non Prec		Archer, Nies, Rader	Archer	Mandamus Denied, Evidentiary Rulings
1996/03/04	Baldwin Hardware Corp. v. FrankSu Enter. Corp.	93-1185	Fed Cir	Sanctions	Prec		Newman, Plager, Rader	Plager	Sanctions, Recusal, Attorney Fees, Attorney Barred
1995/11/16	Tony ColidaColida v. Sony Corporation	95-1375	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D321,184 Portable Cellular Handset Telephone	Archer, Michel, Rader	Rader	Invalid? R, Not Infringed A, Functionality, Anticipation, Peters
1995/10/10	Elmer v. ICC Fabricating, Inc.	94-1503	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D290,620 Vehicle Top Sign Holder	Nies, Lourie, Clevenger	Lourie	Not Infringed R, Functionality, Claim Construction
1995/08/30	Read Corp. v. Freiday	94-1504	Fed Cir	District Court CJ	Non Prec	D263,836 Portable Screening Plant	Rich, Clevenger, Rader	Rich	Damages
1995/07/18	Alopex Indus. v. Seibel	95-1012	Fed Cir	District Court CD	Non Prec	D288,373 Filter Bag	Mayer, Michel, Rader	Michel	Injunction, Contempt
1995/06/02	Alan Tracy, Inc. v. Trans Globe Imports	94-1205	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Non Prec	D312,511 Lens Panel for Lighting Fixture	Archer, Clevenger, Schall	Schall	Not Infringed R, Indeterminate Length
1995/05/08	Arbek Mfg. v. Moazzam	94-1484	Fed Cir	District Court CJ	Prec	D313,323 Cabinet or Similar Article	Plager, Rader, Schall	Rader	Infringed? R, Injunction, Contempt, Vacated Infringement FInding
1995/04/24	Imagineering, Inc. v. Van Klassens, Inc.	94-1286	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D313,320 Rocking Chair	Newman, Bennett, Rader	Rader	DJ Counterclaim, Sanctions
1995/02/23	Sun Hill Indus. v. Easter Unlimited, Inc.	94-1235	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D310,023 Bag	Michel, Lourie, Rader	Rader	Not Invalid NA, Not Infringed R, Commercial Embodiment, Substantial Similarity, Point of Novelty, Doctrine of Equivalents
1995/01/13	In re GAF Bldg. Materials Corp.	Misc. 417	Fed Cir	Mandamus	Non Prec		Rader, Bennett, Bryson	Rader	Transfer, Convenience of Parties, Mandamus
1994/08/15	Reebok Int'l Ltd. v. J. Baker, Inc.	94-1145	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D341,931 Shoe Upper	Michel, Lourie, Carman	Michel	Preliminary Injunction, No Irreparable Harm, Denial Affirmed
1994/07/07	Tone Bros. v. Sysco Corp.	92-1347	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D277,363 Jar or Similar Article	Plager, Clevenger, Schall	Schall	Invalid? R, Public Use Bar, Experimental Use Exception
1994/04/12	Swede Indus. v. Zebco Corp.	93-1403	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D307,621 Fishing Reel	Mayer, Rader, Schall	Rader	Not Invalid R, Infringed? R, Obviousness, Suggestion to Combine, Estoppel
1994/03/22	Gen. Electro Music Corp. v. Samick Music Corp.	93-1299	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D310,232 Electronic Baby Grand Piano	Nies, Lourie, Clevenger	Lourie	Not Invalid NA, Unenforceable, Inequitable Conduct, Jury Finding, Petition to Make Special, Intent
1994/03/08	Beverly Hills Fan Co. v. Royal Sovereign Corp.	92-1326	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D304,229 Ceiling Fan	Newman, Smith, Plager	Plager	Personal Jurisdiction, Dismissal Reversed
1994/01/31	Vitacco v. Toastmaster, Inc.	93-1273	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D301,795 Pancake D303,312 Waffle	Archer, Plager, Schall	Archer	Not Infringed A, No Protection of Idea, Sanctions, Rule 11
1993/12/20	Broyhill Furniture Indus. v. Craftmaster Furniture Corp.	91-1014	Fed Cir	District Court CJ	Prec	D274,485 Seat	Rich, Plager, Lourie	Lourie	Inequitable Conduct, Unenforceable, Rule 68 (b), Set Aside Judgment, Void Judgment, Fraud Upon the Court
1993/12/13	Duncan v. Stuetzle	93-1474	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	? Foot Massage Chair	Clevenger, Bennett, Schall	Clevenger	Pleading Requirements
1993/12/07	In re Harvey	92-1564	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Vase	Newman, Michel, Schall	Michel	Not Invalid R, Obviousness, Design Concept, Suggestion to Combine,
1993/09/14	Gargoyles, Inc. v. United States	93-5026	Fed Cir	CC J	Non Prec	D270,165 Eyeglasses	Archer, Bennett, Rader	Rader	Not Infringed A, Ordinary Observer Test
1993/08/10	Monoflo Int'l, Inc. v. Larand Int'l	92-1487	Fed Cir	District Court JDV	Non Prec	D299,008 Bag Clip	Rich, Mayer, Schall	Rich	Invalid A, Obviousness, Functional Standpoint, Exceptional Case
1993/07/20	Payless Shoesource, Inc. v. Reebok Int'l Ltd.	93-1035	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D326,353 Shoe Upper D325,809 Shoe Upper	Mayer, Lourie, Rader	Lourie	Ordinary Observer Test, Commercial Embodiment, As a Whole, Preliminary Injunction
1993/07/12	Katz v. Lear Siegler, Inc.	91-1094	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D230,400 Pistol	Newman, Archer, Rader	Archer	Standing, Notice of Assignment, Venue
1993/06/29	Keystone Retaining Wall Sys., Inc. v. Westrock, Inc.	92-1265	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D298,463 Retaining Wall Block	Newman, Plager, Lourie	Lourie	Not Infringed A, Matter of Concern, Ordinary Observer, Actual Confusion
1993/06/01	In re Butera	93-1041	Fed Cir	BPAI	Non Prec	Application Combined Insect Repellant and Air Freshener	Rich, Plager D, Lourie	Lourie	Not Invalid R, Obviousness, Analogous Art, One of Ordinary Skill in the Art, Of the Type Claimed
1993/05/05	Rubbermaid, Inc. v. Tucker Housewares Corp.	93-1298	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	?	Rader, Bennett, Schall	Rader	Preliminary Injunction, Additional Findings
1993/03/11	In re Klein	92-1420	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Roof or Siding Shingle	Rich, Bennett, Newman	Rich	Not Invalid R, Obviousness, Multiple Embodiments, Suggestion to Combine
1993/02/16	L.A. Gear, Inc. v. Thom McAn Shoe Co.	89-1488	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D299,081 Shoe Upper	Newman, Mayer, Plager	Newman, Mayer Concur in part, Dissent in part	Infringed A, Functionality, Obviousness, Commercial Success, Sugestion to Combine, Infringement, Substantial Similarity, Commercial Embodiment, Labeling, Willful Infringement, Opinion of Counsel, Adverse Inference, Copying, Damages, Attorney Fees
1993/02/01	In re Carlson	92-1248	Fed Cir	BPAI RE	Prec	D289,855 Dual Compartment Bottle or Similar Article	Nies, Lourie, Clevenger	Clevenger	Invalid A, Petition for Rehearing, Analogous Prior Art
1992/12/16	In re Carlson	92-1248	Fed Cir	BPAI RE	Prec	D289,855 Dual Compartment Bottle or Similar Article	Nies, Lourie, Clevenger	Clevenger	Invalid A, Obviousness, Foreign Patent, 102(a) Prior Art, 102(d) Prior Art, Suggestion to Combine
1992/11/17	Pepitone v. American Standard	92-1284	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D301,842 Water Temperature Guage	Rich, Plager, Clevenger	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A, Interference, Subject Matter Jurisdiction, Substantial Similarity, Co-Inventorship, Judicial Notice
1992/11/03	Laich Indus. Corp. v. Baskin-Robbins United States Co.	92-1177	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	?	Newman, Skelton, Lourie	Lourie	Jurisdiction, Notice of Appeal, Final Judgment
1992/09/08	Braun, Inc. v. Dynamics Corp. of Am.	91-1329	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D271,176 Hand Held Electric Mixer	Rich, Plager, Cohn DJ	Cohn DJ	Infringed A, Infringement, Impulse Buy, Ordinary Observer, Jury Ordinary Observers, Inequitable Conduct, Willful Infringement, Treble Damages, Section 289
1992/07/10	Read Corp. v. Portec, Inc.	91-1068	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D263,836 Portable Screening Plant	Nies, Archer, Michel	Nies	Not Infringed R, Infringement, Functional Features, Evidence of Infringement, Enhanced Damages, Attorney Fees
1991/11/08	Eldon Indus. v. Vanier Mfg.	90-1117	Fed Cir	District Court J	Non Prec	D271,741 Soldering Iron Tip	Markey, Mayer, Lourie	Lourie	Invalid R, Not Infringed R, Functionality, Dictated Design, Inequitable Conduct
1991/11/01	Johannsen v. Pay Less Drug Storesorthwest, Inc.	91-1278	Fed Cir	District Court J	Non Prec	D268,639 Pumpkin Carving Knife	Rich, Newman, Rader	Rich	Not Infringed A, Infringement, Functional Features,
1991/10/01	National Presto Indus. v. Dazey Corp.	91-1127	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	?	Newman, Michel, Plager	Newman	Preliminary Injunction, Trade Dress Sufficient
1991/07/03	Lund Indus. v. Go Indus.	90-1506	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D303,239 Truck Visor	Lourie, Rader, Cowen	Rader	Infringement, Ordinary Observer Test, KSM, Compare Accused Device to Claim
1991/06/07	Vas-Cath, Inc. v. Sakharam D. Mahurkar	90-1528	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	Application ?	Rich, Michel, Plager	Rich	120 Priority, Written Description Utility from Design,
1991/03/25	Indep. Prods. Co. v. Tamor Plastics Corp.	90-1431	Fed Cir	District Court J	Non Prec	D269,238 Hanger	Lourie, Skelton, Rader	Rader	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Obviousness, Infringement, Inequitable Conduct, Expert Testimony
1991/02/15	John D. Brush & Co. v. U. S. Int'l Trade Com.	90-1315	Fed Cir	ITC	Non Prec	D289,582 Portable Fire Resistant Case	Mayer, Plager, Rader	Per Curiam	Not Infringed A,
1991/01/09	Oakley, Inc. v. Int'l Tropic-Cal, Inc.	90-1300	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D293,450 Sunglasses	Markey, Archer, Michel	Archer	Preliminary Injunction, Vacated, Insufficient Findings of Fact
1990/10/30	Johannsen v. Pay Less Drug Stores Northwest, Inc.	89-1688	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D268,639 Pumpkin Carving Knife	Rich, Baldwin, Lifland DJ	Rich	Jurisdiction, Final Judgment
1990/10/11	In re Webb	90-1176	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Femoral Hip Stem	Archer, Plager, Clevenger	Clevenger	Not Invalid R, Ornamental, Normal and Intended Use, Matter of Concern
1990/07/25	Katz v. Lear Siegler, Inc.	89-1730	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D230,400 Pistol	Newman, Archer, Alarcon	Newman	Preliminary Injunction, Concurrent Litigation, Joinder
1990/07/11	Chrysler Motors Corp. v. Auto Body Panels of Ohio, Inc.	89-1656	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D299,019 Truck Fender	Michel, Skelton, Plager	Plager	Invalid? A, Preliminary Injunction, Functionality
1990/04/03	Cicena Ltd. v. Columbia Telcoms. Group	90-1053	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D300,134 Illuminated Telephone	Rich, Skelton, Michel	Rich	Preliminary Injunction
1989/07/28	Application Art Labs. Co. v. Tamao Morita	89-1270	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Non Prec	D247,468 Separable Magnetic Lock for a Purse or Similar Article	Archer, Mayer, Michel	Michel	Motion to Dissolve Preliminary Injunction
1989/06/26	Racing Strollers, Inc. v. TRI Industries, Inc.	89-1241	Fed Cir	District Court IA	Prec	D297,525 Frame for a Baby Stroller	Markey, Friedman, Rich, Nies, Newman, Bissell, Archer, Mayer, Michel	Rich	Interloculatory Appeal, Certified Question, 120 Priority
1989/04/20	Chaparral Communications v. Boman Industries, Inc.	88-1493	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D272,910 Feedhorn for Parabolic Antennae	?	?	Unenforceable, Inequitable Conduct, Attorney Fees
1989/03/08	Benchcraft, Inc. v. Broyhill Furniture Indus.	88-1345	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Non Prec	D274,485 Seat	Friedman, Nichols, Nies	Friedman	Unenforceable, Inequitable Conduct, Intent
1988/11/17	John Thomas Batts, Inc. v. S.O. Textiles Co.	88-1134	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Non Prec	D267,920 Garment Hanger Body	?	?	Obviousness
1988/10/11	In re Mann	88-1423	Fed Cir	BPAI	Prec	Application Wrought Iron Table	Rich, Smith, Nies	Rich	Public Use, Experimental Use, No Scope
1988/09/06	Cleo D. Mathis & Vico Prods. Mfg. Co. v. Spears	86-1574	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D244,462 Whirlpool Jet Nozzle for Bathtubs and the Like	Markey, Rich, Newman	Markey	Design Patent Withdrawn, Exceptional Case, Attorney Fees
1988/07/29	Avia Group Int'l, Inc. v. L.A. Gear Cal., Inc.	87-1505	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D284,420 Shoe Sole D287,301 Shoe Upper	Smith, Nies, Mayer	Nies	Not Invalid A, Functionality, Obviousness, Infringement, Willfulness, Attorney Fees
1988/06/17	Phlaphongphanich v. Fabjancic	88-1128	Fed Cir	BPAI Interfer	Non Prec	Application Orthodontic Baby Nipple	Markey, Nichols, Bissell	Markey	Interference, Conception, Functionality
1988/02/03	Lee v. Dayton-Hudson Corp.	87-1311	Fed Cir	District Court J	Prec	D259,142 Massage Implement	Newman, Cowen, Bissell	Newman	Not Infringed A, Ornamental, Commercial Embodiment, Doctrine of Equivalents
1987/12/30	FMC Corp. v. Hennessy Indus.	87-1268	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D243,551 Tire Changing Apparatus or Similar Article	Markey, Rich, Mayer	Markey	Not Infringed A, Attorney Fees, Inequitable Conduct
1987/07/02	Chemlawn Services Corp. v. GNC Pumps, Inc.	87-1093	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D238,671 Spray Nozzle	Friedman, Davis, Nichols	Davis	Preliminary Injunction, Findings to Support, Loss of Jurisdiction
1987/06/24	Norco Prods. v. Mecca Dev., Inc.	86-1075	Fed Cir	District Court OD	Prec	D246,109 Fluid Filter	Friedman, Baldwin, Newman	Friedman	No Jurisdiction
1987/02/02	In re Sung Nam Cho	86-973	Fed Cir	BPAI D	Prec	Application Bottle Cap	Newman D, Miller, Archer	Miller, Newman Dissent	Not Invalid R, Obviousness, Suggestion to Combine, Functional Considerations Motivate
1986/11/13	Power Controls Corp. v. Hybrinetics, Inc.	86-1041	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec	D281,580 Packaging Container for Electrical Switches	Friedman, Smith, Bissell	Friedman	No Preliminary Injunction V
1986/09/10	Pac. Furniture Mfg. Co. v. Preview Furniture Corp.	86-787	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D258,100 Armchair D258,101 Armchair	Friedman, Davis, Newman	Davis	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, No Inequitable Conduct, Exceptional Case, Treble Damages, Willful Infringement
1986/07/28	Chaparral Communs., Inc. v. Boman Indus.	86-1061	Fed Cir	District Court PI	Prec		Markey, Friedman, Archer	Archer	No Jurisdiction
1986/03/05	Unette Corp. v. Unit Pack Co.	85-2201	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D267,927 Dispensing Container	Davis, Smith, Bissell	Smith	Infringed A, No Attorney Fees
1985/12/03	Kangaroos U.S.A., Inc. v. Caldor, Inc.	84-1688	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec		Markey, Bennett, Newman	Newman	No Inequitable Conduct R, Priority
1985/11/14	Interpart Corp. v. Imos Italia	84-1690	Fed Cir	District Court OAF	Prec	D263,130 Rear View Mirror	Friedman, Rich, Bissell	Rich	Exceptional Case, Attorney Fees
1984/12/20	Trans-World Mfg. Corp. v. Al Nyman & Sons, Inc.	84-503	Fed Cir	District Court JT	Prec	D257,497 Eyeglass Display Holder D258,099 Eyeglass Display Rack	Friedman, Cowen, Newman	Friedman	Invalid A, Obviousness, Suggestion to Combine, Secondary Considerations, 30 Days Notice, Co-Inventorship, Injunction, Amend Complaint After Verdict, Damages
1984/11/30	Feuling v. Wood	84-543	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D259,490 Fan Housing for an Air Cooled Engine D259,491 Fan Housing for an Air Cooled Engine D261,654 Mounting Stand for Attaching an Accessory to an Engine	Baldwin, Smith, Nies	Baldwin	Invalid A, Functional, Attorney Fees
1984/09/28	Shelcore, Inc. v. Durham Indus.	84-791	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D257,780 Simulative Driving Toy	Markey, Baldwin, Smith	Smith	Not Invalid A, Not Infringed A, Double Patenting, Attorney Fees
1984/07/03	Petersen Mfg. Co. v. Central Purchasing, Inc.	83-1006	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Prec	D261,096 Hand Tool	Markey, Bennett, Nies	Nies	Invalid A, Obviousness
1984/04/19	Fiberglass in Motion, Inc. v. Hindelang	83-1266	Fed Cir	District Court SJ	Non Prec	D244,182 Camper Shell	Bennett, Skelton, Miller	Bennett	Not Invalid A, Infringed A, Willful Infringement, Attorney Fees, 60(b)
1984/02/14	Litton Sys. v. Whirlpool Corp.	83-1004	Fed Cir	District Court BT	Prec	D226,990 Microwave Oven	Kashiwa, Nichols, Bennett	Nichols	Not Invalid A, Not Infringed R, Infringement, Obviousness, Commercial Success, Three-Way Test, Crowded Prior Art
1983/04/25	In re Salmon	82-603	Fed Cir	PTAB D	Prec	Stool	Friedman, Davis, Nichols D	Friedman	Invalid A, Priority
1982/03/12	In re Rosen	81-602	CCPA	USPTO		Application Table	Markey, Rich, Baldwin, Miller, Nies	Nies	Not Invalid R, Primary Reference, Obviousness
1980/02/21	In re Zahn	79-560	CCPA	USPTO		Application Drill Tool	Markey, Rich, Baldwin, Miller, Nies	Rich	Not Invalid R, Portion Claiming
1967/03/16	In re Hruby	7652	CCPA	USPTO		Water Fountain	Worley, Rich, Almond	Rich	Not Invalid R, Article of Manufacture
1956/02/21	In re Glavas	6179	CCPA	USPTO		Application Float	O'Connell, Johnson, Worley, Cole, Jackson	O'Connell	Not Invalid R, Ornamental, Repair
1949/04/12	In re Stevens	5550	CCPA	USPTO		Rotary Brush	Garrett, Hatfield, Jackson, O'Connell, Johnson	Hatfield

Cookie	Duration	Description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional	11 months	The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance	11 months	This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy	11 months	The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.