File wrapper citations in this article link to the documents in ProSearch. A free Design Patent Pro account is all that is needed to open them.
This week we look at design applications abandoned between November 9 and November 15, 2026 whose files are open to the public and that drew at least one rejection. There were 27 of them: 24 Hague designations and 3 domestic applications.
The file to read first is a domestic application for an under-desk drawer. The applicant’s own Amazon listing was cited against it, and a Rule 130(a) declaration was filed to remove it. The examiner held that nothing in the record tied the seller to the inventor, made the rejection final, and the application was abandoned. Elsewhere, two Hague applicants saw an intervening disclosure treated as prior art because no certified copy of the priority application had reached the USPTO, and a third was told its priority claim was too old when the dates say otherwise. A photographed medical pad, a set of statements that widened or muddied the claim, and three replies that fixed only part of the problem round out the week.
1. The Week in Numbers
- 27 abandoned histories reviewed: 24 Hague designations and 3 domestic applications. Every one had at least one rejection, which is how the batch is collected.
- How they ended: all 27 for failure to respond to an Office action. 5 had received a final rejection.
- Replies on the merits: 5, all followed by a final rejection. Interviews of record: 1. Restriction requirements: 1.
- Rejections under 35 USC 112: 23 files. Four files were rejected only on prior art.
- 102 rejections: 6 files. 103 rejections: 3. Section 171 (no article of manufacture): 1. Double patenting: 5 files: two identical designs rejected against each other, two lamps refused against each other, and one lamp refused over an application outside the batch.
- Priority problems noted by the examiner: 5 files. In 4, no certified copy of the foreign application had been received. In 1, the examiner denied priority as more than six months old, although the dates fall inside the six-month period.
- Rule 130 declarations: 1. Rule 132 declarations: none. Appeals: none. LKQ v. GM cited by an examiner or an applicant: none.
Method note: these are application-level counts across the 27 file histories. One file may carry several grounds, so the categories overlap. The batch is one week long and dominated by Hague designations, so treat the numbers as a snapshot, not as rates.
2. A Declaration That Never Connected the Seller
Domestic Application No. 29/920,460 (drawer) was filed December 11, 2023 for a clamp-on drawer that mounts under a desk. The examiner rejected it under 102(a)(1), and also under 103, over an Amazon listing for a “VIVO 14 inch Clamp-on Sliding Under Table Drawer,” first available August 28, 2023, a little over three months before filing.
The reply said the listing showed the applicant’s own product. In the remarks, VIVO was “a wholly owned subsidiary of the assignee,” CKnapp Sales, Inc. The supporting Rule 130(a) declaration came from one named inventor, identified as an engineering manager at “CKnapp Sales, Inc., (dba VIVO)” and confirmed that the listed product was the same as the claimed design. The declaration included the full 18 USC 1001 acknowledgment. It said the declarant was an inventor and a designer of the product, but it did not explain how the design passed from the inventors to the seller or attach anything showing the corporate relationship. The remarks and the declaration also described that relationship differently: a subsidiary in one, a trade name in the other.
The final rejection of April 2026 held that the arguments and declaration “did not provide any evidence that the seller VIVO … got the drawer directly from the inventor,” and that “there is no connection made between CKnapp Sales Inc. and VIVO.” Both rejections were repeated. The 103 rejection rested on a single reference. Removing the listing’s logo and screw heads and changing the thread shape were called “the simple substitution of one known design element for another,” and the examiner cited In re Daniels for the point that a logo does not change the underlying design. The applicant did not reply again.
A Rule 130(a) declaration has to show that the disclosure was made by the inventor or by someone who obtained the design from the inventor. Saying that the product is the same as the claim proves only the anticipation. Explain who created the design, how it reached the seller, and how the seller relates to the applicant, and attach something that proves the relationship: a trade name filing, a corporate record, or the seller account details. Then make sure the remarks describe the relationship the same way.
3. Priority Left Unperfected
A design application gets six months of foreign priority under 35 USC 172, and the claim is not perfected until a certified copy of the foreign application is on file. Five files this week turned on priority.
A label refused on three grounds, one of them because priority was not perfected. Application No. 35/524,411 (label) claimed priority to an EU application filed October 30, 2024, but no certified copy had been filed. The examiner rejected the claim under 102(a)(1) over an online reference available December 8, 2024, after the priority date but before the January 20, 2025 filing date, and pointed out that the applicant “may overcome the rejection” by perfecting priority. The same action refused the claim under 35 USC 171, because the reproductions showed a graphic symbol that “can be applied to many different articles,” and under 112(a) and (b), because the appearance of the label itself could not be determined. The examiner warned that adding an article now would be new matter. It is the same lesson as last week’s woven leather pattern.
A cup and an intervening online post. In Application No. 35/525,288 (cup), priority to a Malaysian application filed December 4, 2023 was not granted because the certified copy had not been received. Without it, the examiner wrote, a post published February 2, 2024 “qualifies as prior art under 35 USC 102(a)(1)” against the May 29, 2024 filing date.
A priority claim denied in error. In Application No. 35/525,338 (laser therapeutic apparatus), the examiner wrote that the priority application, filed December 15, 2023, was dated more than six months before the June 4, 2024 filing date, so the effective filing date “remains 06/04/2024.” Those dates are less than six months apart. The action’s closing line also says the claim stands rejected under 102(a)(1), but the action sets out no 102 rejection and applies no reference. A reply could have corrected both points. None was filed.
Two more where the copy never arrived. In 35/524,964 (probe pin for integrated circuit testing), the Office’s attempt to retrieve the Korean application through the priority document exchange “FAILED,” and in 35/525,018 (transcatheter device) the examiner noted that a certified copy with the correct retrieval code had not been received. Neither file had a prior art rejection, so the gap cost nothing yet.
For a Hague filing that designates the United States, check that the priority claim falls within six months and that the certified copy, or a working retrieval code, reaches the USPTO. Then check the examiner’s priority finding against the dates. The priority date is often the only thing standing between the design and the applicant’s own launch.
4. Photographs, a Scanning Excuse, and a Statement That Disclaimed Nothing
Application No. 35/003,203 (medical pad) was filed through Hague with photographs. The examiner rejected the claim under 112(a) and (b) on two grounds. The pad sat on a wrinkled, textured surface that “may be the background or may be a part of the claim,” and the black straps “blend and merge into each other and the sides of the pad,” so their attachment points and hardware could not be made out. The examiner suggested professional line drawings, or new photographs on a plain white background, as long as they kept the original appearance.
The reply suggested the problems “could well have resulted from the Office’s scanning and imaging (downsizing)” of the originals, filed new photographs with the background cleaned up, and stated that the background, the color and the strap hardware form no part of the claim, the hardware being functional. The final rejection repeated both grounds against the replacement figures: shadows and texture remained, and the straps still merged.
Two lessons. A statement in the remarks that a feature is not claimed does not disclaim it; in a photograph, only removing or clearly bounding the feature does that. And arguing that a feature is functional does not cure a drawing that fails to show it. USPTO continuity data list a US continuation filed from this application, so the applicant appears to be trying again.
5. Replies That Fixed Part of the Problem
Five applicants replied on the merits, and every one of them received a final rejection. Three of the replies show the same pattern: the fix addressed what the examiner had illustrated and left the rest.
- Three replacement figures, and a utility application as support. In 35/523,169 (LED screen for vehicles), the reply amended three figures and explained the dividing line and the oblique shading by citing paragraphs of the applicant’s US utility application, the priority document. The final rejection noted that “only three replacement figures were submitted,” asked for a complete set, and found the views “stretched and distorted to approximate perspective,” with broken lines that no statement explained.
- Views moved to an appendix. In 35/522,835 (hair straightener), after an interview the applicant removed six figures from the drawings and placed them in an appendix. The examiner accepted that those views were no longer part of the claim and noted that anything in the appendix “forms no part of the” claimed design, and made final rejections over the power cord, leftover gray tonal shading and blurred, uneven line weight in the remaining views.
- A broken line statement that the drawings did not match. In 35/522,741 (profile for painting frame), the reply added a statement that the broken-line interior forms no part of the claim. The final rejection pointed out that the front of the same through-hole was still drawn in solid lines with surface shading, so where the claimed interior ended could not be determined.
When an examiner’s annotations show examples, treat them as examples. Before replying, check every view against every other view and send a complete replacement set.
6. Statements That Widen or Confuse the Claim
Several examiners objected to text that applicants had added around the drawings. The list makes a useful checklist for anyone preparing a specification.
- Reservation of rights. In domestic Application No. 29/874,921 (sack), the specification said that color and texture may or may not form part of the claimed design, that the invention “can be any part, portion, element, or combination of elements” of the design, and that the applicant reserved the right to file continuations converting the straps, tag, drawstring and stitching to broken lines. The examiner required its removal because “this statement expands the scope of the claim.” The same action said the examiner could find no art teaching the differences between the claimed bag and the closest reference. The application was abandoned anyway, over drawings whose views did not align.
- “Indeterminate length” and “profile.” In 35/522,741 (above), a statement that the broken lines show a separation “which represents an indeterminate length” was rejected as suggesting the design could have any length; the examiner supplied a standard symbolic break statement instead. “Profile” was objected to because it “is not an article of manufacture but an outline of an article.”
- A color disclaimer on a colored drawing. In 35/525,402 (drink can), “Protection is not sought for specific colors” sat beside a reproduction with green blocks, and the examiner could not tell whether the green marked contrasting surfaces or a disclaimed area. The same action noted that the bottom and rear were never shown and, under In re Zahn, form no part of the claim.
- Disclaiming words while claiming a logo. In 35/525,288 (cup), a statement that “no claim is made to any right to the exclusive use of the letters, words and numerals appearing in the design” conflicted with a brand name drawn in solid lines.
- Function, material and the claim itself. In 35/525,338, a statement about metal and synthetic resin and treating the skin with a laser was found to have “no bearing on the ornamental appearance.” In 35/526,886 (mug), the examiner suggested cancelling the claim sentence repeated before the claim, and in 35/525,529 (lamp), a four-part statement of the product’s name, purpose, feature and best view was called unnecessary, though correction was optional.
7. Prior Art and Double Patenting Notes
- One creator’s videos as the whole combination. In 35/525,337 (isothermal cup), all three 103 references were frames from YouTube comparison videos by the same reviewer, all published March 1, 2025. The stated reason to combine was that the changes were “well within the experience, creativity and common sense of a designer of ordinary skill.” No reply tested that rationale.
- A retailer’s web page as the primary reference. In 35/525,192 (tin can), the primary reference was a Croatian retailer’s product page dated December 2, 2024, combined with a 2018 Chinese design patent for the longer peel tab and plain lid.
- Prior art applied to an unclear claim. In 35/003,275 (pet feeder), the examiner found the claim indefinite but held the ornamental appearance “sufficient for comparison with the prior art” and rejected it under 102 over a cat slow feeder first available July 27, 2023, treating the reference’s logo as a de minimis difference.
- Two identical designations. 35/524,996 and 35/525,006 (transcatheter devices) were each provisionally rejected over the other. The heading calls it same-invention double patenting under 35 USC 171, which a terminal disclaimer cannot cure, while the text calls it obviousness-type. Either way, one of two identical designs had to go.
8. What to Take From the Week
- A Rule 130(a) declaration must show how the design got from the inventor to the person who disclosed it. Prove the corporate relationship with documents, and describe it the same way in the remarks and the declaration.
- For Hague filings, confirm that priority is claimed within six months and that the certified copy or a working retrieval code reaches the USPTO. If the examiner gets the priority dates wrong, say so in a reply.
- File graphic symbols and logos for the US on an article. An article cannot be added later.
- Photograph designs on a plain background with every claimed feature visible. A statement in the remarks does not disclaim what a photograph shows.
- Treat an examiner’s annotations as examples. Check every view and send a complete set of replacement figures.
- Strip reservation-of-rights language, “indeterminate length,” color and lettering disclaimers that contradict the drawings, and functional or material descriptions from the US designation.
- Do not designate the same design twice.