A Pattern Is Not an Article: What 19 abandoned design applications show and what practitioners might consider

File wrapper citations in this article link to the documents in ProSearch. A free Design Patent Pro account is all that is needed to open them.

This week we look at design applications abandoned between November 2 and November 8, 2026 whose files are open to the public and that drew at least one rejection. There were 19 of them: 17 Hague designations and 2 domestic applications.

Most of these applicants never replied, so the lessons are in what the examiners wrote. A leather pattern filed through Hague was refused because a pattern is not an article of manufacture, and in an interview the examiner explained why the applicant’s own Instagram posts could not fix that. One applicant lost five hairdressing accessories to the same problem: interior features visible only through a grate in a single view. And the eighth member of last week’s pan lid family was given up after the applicant argued about parts of the lid it had chosen not to claim.

1. The Week in Numbers

  • 19 abandoned histories reviewed: 17 Hague designations and 2 domestic applications. Every one had at least one rejection, which is how the batch is collected.
  • How they ended: 18 for failure to respond to an Office action, and 1 by express abandonment. 2 had received a final rejection.
  • Rejections under 35 USC 112: all 19, almost all about the drawings. Section 171 (no article of manufacture): 1.
  • 102 rejections: 1, over two Amazon listings. 103 rejections: 2. Double patenting: 1, a provisional rejection over seven related applications, answered with a terminal disclaimer.
  • Replies on the merits: 2. One more applicant called the examiner and then let the file go. Restriction requirements: 2. Rule 130 or Rule 132 declarations: none. Appeals: none.
  • LKQ v. GM cited by an examiner or an applicant: none.

Method note: these are application-level counts across the 19 file histories. One file may carry several grounds, so the categories overlap. The batch is one week long and dominated by Hague designations, so treat the numbers as a snapshot, not as rates.

2. A Pattern Is Not an Article

Application No. 35/525,185 was filed through Hague as a “woven leather pattern,” described as “a repeatable pattern which can be rotated 180 degrees.” The reproduction showed the pattern alone. The examiner refused the claim under 35 USC 171 because “a ‘pattern’ is not an article of manufacture,” citing In re Schnell and Ex parte Strijland for the rule that a surface design must be shown applied to an article.

The inventor then called the examiner. He explained that the pattern was meant for clothing and other fashion articles, and pointed to one of the references the examiner had cited: the applicant’s own Instagram account, showing the pattern in use. The examiner’s answer is worth reading in full. Adding an article now would be new matter, because the original disclosure showed none, and the Instagram posts could not supply one because they were found by the examiner and were never part of the application. The examiner suggested that the best course might be a continuation-in-part. The examiner also described a claim that would have worked: a “fabric sheet” or “sheet material,” with a portion of the pattern bounded by broken lines, and if desired a statement in the preamble that the sheet is intended to be tiled across the surface of an article.

The applicant did not file a CIP or a reply. Two points for anyone filing surface designs through Hague. First, some offices will register a pattern by itself, but the US designation needs an article in the title and in the reproductions from the start. Second, a CIP would give any design shown on an article only the CIP’s own filing date, so the applicant’s own social media posts would have to be checked against the one-year grace period before relying on that route.

3. Five End Pieces, One Grate

One applicant designated the United States for five accessories titled “End piece for hairdressing apparatus”: Application Nos. 35/525,172, 35/525,174, 35/525,188, 35/525,202 and 35/525,221. Each had eight views. The refusals, issued between April 1 and April 6, 2026, are nearly identical.

Each attachment has a grate on its back face, and behind the grate are rings, planes and curved sections that appear in only one view. The examiner explained that the applicant was claiming a three-dimensional article whose interior was “only shown in a single planar view,” and asked, feature by feature, whether the surfaces behind the grate were coplanar or set at different depths. The suggested cure was the usual one: show the interior in more views, or put it in broken lines or color it to remove it from the claim. The examiner also objected to the title, because “End Piece” and “Apparatus” are not specific names for an article, and in one file suggested “Accessory for Hairdressing Device.”

None of the five was answered. A set of reproductions that satisfies a European or WIPO examiner may not satisfy a US one, especially for features seen through openings. If a family of related designs is going to the US through Hague, check one designation’s reproductions against US practice before filing, because whatever is wrong with one will usually be wrong with all of them.

4. Arguing What You Did Not Claim

Last week we reported that seven circular pan lids with windows of different shapes, all filed in December 2024, were expressly abandoned in October. Application No. 29/980,354 (circular pan lid with a diamond shaped window) is the eighth. Its express abandonment was signed October 8, 2026 but not recorded until November 2, so it falls in this week’s batch.

This one went further than the others. The applicant split off the flat-lid embodiments for a continuation, then elected a group from a four-way restriction. The elected design claimed only a flat diamond-shaped area around the window, with the rest of the circular lid in broken lines. The examiner rejected it under 103 over a YouTube video of a lid with a similar window, combined with two other lids, reasoning that concentric shapes and unequal angles were “commonplace in the field of lids with simple shaped elements.”

The reply argued overall appearance, including the “surrounding rectilinear lid configuration” and the way the lid frames the window. The final rejection of August 4, 2026 answered that point directly. “The claimed design ends at the parallelogram shaped dot-dash broken line boundaries,” and the circular outline of the lid, shown in broken lines, does not affect the scope of the claim. Citing In re Zahn, the examiner compared the claimed portion with the matching portion of the prior art, “apples-to-apples,” and found no support in the drawings for the layering the applicant described. The applicant did file a terminal disclaimer over seven related applications, which cleared the double patenting rejection.

The lesson is the other side of partial design claiming. A claim limited to a small area is broader against copyists, but it also invites comparison with any reference that has a similar area, and arguments about the unclaimed surroundings will not help. If the surroundings matter to patentability, claim them. Neither side cited LKQ, and the rejection’s one-sentence “commonplace” rationale was never tested on appeal.

5. Prior Art: The Right Test, and a Thin Rationale

A garden planter, refused under the correct test. Last week, two anticipation refusals spoke of references that were “visually similar.” In Application No. 35/525,343 (garden planter), the examiner made two 102(a)(1) refusals over raised garden beds sold on Amazon since at least June 20, 2020 and April 14, 2021, years before the May 2025 filing. Both refusals applied the ordinary observer test as written: the designs “must be substantially the same.” The examiner kept both embodiments together without a restriction and, separately, required brackets and dash-dot lines for the symbolic breaks in the planter’s length.

A tire gauge and the word “commonplace.” In Application No. 35/524,369 (tire pressure gauge), the examiner rejected the claim under 103 over one gauge in view of another. The second reference supplied a tiered transition at the tip and a divided screen, and the combination also required removing slanted grips from the primary reference. The entire reason given for those changes was one sentence: the features “are all ornamental features that are commonplace in the field of tire pressure gauges.” Under LKQ, a reply would ask where in the record that conclusion is supported, and why a designer would remove a feature from the primary reference. No reply was filed.

The same refusal recites that it “was unintentionally not communicated to the International Bureau within the applicable time period” and was being notified under Rule 18(1)(c)(ii) of the Hague Common Regulations. The USPTO’s position, set out in MPEP 2950, is that a missed refusal period does not by itself give the holder a US patent. Protection in the United States still comes only from an issued patent.

6. Adding a Line, Removing a Line

A bridle that could not be redrawn. Application No. 35/522,620 (part of bridle) is one of the two files where the applicant replied on the merits. The first action found the scope unclear because the padded surfaces were bounded partly by solid lines and partly by broken lines that merged into each other. The reply redrew four views. The final rejection of April 3, 2026 found new matter in a solid perimeter line that did not appear in the original reproductions, and added that “the complete removal of solid line from the claim has introduced new matter.” To take something out of a claim, the applicant must convert it to broken lines, not erase it. The examiner then wrote that it was “not clear to the Examiner if there are any amendments” that could cure the drawings without new matter. The application was abandoned.

Magnets you cannot see. In domestic Application No. 29/948,649 (mobile device charging cable for keychain), the drawings used broken lines to show magnets inside the cable, and arrows to show how it folds. The examiner objected to both: broken lines may not show “hidden features/surfaces that cannot be seen through opaque materials,” and arrows indicating motion describe function, not appearance. The examiner did accept the title without requiring “set,” treating the claim as a cable and holder together. No reply was filed.

7. Hague Formalities That Turn Into US Rejections

The remaining Hague files were refused on drawings and descriptions that would likely have passed in the applicant’s home office. The objections are a checklist.

  • Descriptive and feature statements. In 35/524,959 (coffee machine), a paragraph describing the machine’s panels and drawers was struck as “unnecessary and descriptive.” In 35/525,001 (accumulator charging apparatus), the feature statement was objected to as redundant.
  • Function and foreign view labels. In 35/525,249 (optical fiber termination unit), the examiner struck a description of how the unit works, objected that “usage state view” and “partial disassembled views” have “no special meaning in US design practice,” and objected to a reference view described as not part of the claim when it showed claimed features.
  • Duplicates and the wrong kind of broken line. In 35/525,342 (handbag), two reproductions were duplicates, and a statement disclaiming parts “shown in dotted lines” did not match the dashed lines actually used.
  • Photographs and dark or uneven views. 35/524,948 (vehicle light) used blurry photographs with glare. In 35/524,639 (electricity meter), the views were so dark that details could not be made out. 35/525,279 (needle cap holder) and 35/525,388 (comb attachment for hair styling device) were refused for features shown differently from view to view.

In almost every file, the examiner offered the same exit: convert the unclear areas to broken lines and add a statement that they form no part of the claim. None of these applicants took it.

8. What to Take From the Week

  • File surface patterns for the US on an article, or as sheet material with a broken-line boundary. An article cannot be added later, and the applicant’s own posts will not supply one.
  • Show interior features seen through grates and openings in more than one view, or disclaim them from the start.
  • When a family goes to the US through Hague, check one designation against US practice before filing all of them.
  • Do not argue unclaimed surroundings to distinguish a partial claim. If they matter, claim them.
  • Answer a one-sentence “commonplace” rationale with LKQ, especially when the combination requires removing a feature from the primary reference.
  • Remove subject matter by converting it to broken lines, never by erasing it, and never add lines that were not in the original reproductions.
  • Strip descriptive, functional and foreign-style statements from the US designation, and match the broken line statement to the lines actually drawn.
Design Patent Prosecution Update, abandoned November 2 to 8, 2026: A Pattern Is Not an Article
Picture of Robert G. Oake, Jr.

Robert G. Oake, Jr.

is a Registered Patent Attorney and Board Certified in Patent Litigation, Civil Trial Law, and Civil Practice Advocacy by the National Board of Trial Advocacy. He holds two LL.M (Master of Law) Degrees, including an LL.M in Patent and Intellectual Property Law (with highest honors) from George Washington University Law School.

Robert served as lead trial and appellate counsel for Egyptian Goddess in the landmark case of Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa. He has tried to verdict as lead counsel cases involving design patents, utility patents, and trademarks, and has argued eleven cases before the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals including an en banc case involving a design patent.

Robert currently serves as one of four members on the Patent Litigation Specialty Program Commission of the National Board of Trial Advocacy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *