File wrapper citations in this article link to the documents in ProSearch. A free Design Patent Pro account is all that is needed to open them.
This week’s batch is the 72 design patents that issued on November 17, 2026 after at least one rejection. Most followed the familiar path from a drawing rejection to replacement sheets to allowance. Ten files are worth keeping.
The one to read first is a Conopco bottle that took more than five years. Its cap was colored but drawn entirely in broken lines, and the examiner held that color spread across an unclaimed curved surface has no boundary. What ended it was a video interview and a page of written notes listing exactly which drawing changes would work. Also this week: a narrower claim in a continuation refused as a “claim shift” and then allowed in a CPA, an application withdrawn from issue a year after allowance, a trade-show reveal that defeated a stranger’s Instagram post under Rule 130(b), a declaration without the 18 USC 1001 warning that passed this time, and three anticipation rejections that fell to the effective filing date. Two patterns were common enough to note here. Five applicants filed replacement drawings that drew a final rejection or an advisory action for new matter. Five more filed a CPA after allowance so that an information disclosure statement would be considered.
The Week in Numbers
- 72 prosecution histories: 50 in the 29 series and 22 in the 30 series. No Hague designations. Median time from filing to issue: about 24 months. The range ran from about 12.5 months (a housing for a dispensing device filed October 29, 2025) to just over 5 years (the bottle in item 1).
- How they got there: about 50 were allowed without a final rejection or an Ex parte Quayle action. 16 received a final rejection and 7 a Quayle action (one file received both). 7 had a restriction requirement. 4 drew an advisory action. 9 used a continued prosecution application (CPA), 5 of them after allowance to have an information disclosure statement considered.
- Rejections by ground: 35 USC 112 in about 50 files. 102 in 16. 103 in 7. Obviousness-type double patenting in 7, all cured by terminal disclaimer. One same-design rejection under 35 USC 171, resolved through a CPA (item 2).
- Rule 130 declarations in 15 files. Three more 102 rejections fell because the reference postdated the effective filing date (item 6). Amazon listings supplied the cited art in at least 8 files, Instagram posts in 3, a YouTube review in 1 and product launch articles in 2. No Rule 132 declarations. Interviews or examiner calls in about 15 files. No notices of appeal.
- LKQ v. GM was cited in one file, by the applicant, through the USPTO’s examination guidance (item 8). No examiner cited it. No rejection quoted the “so related” test of Glavas or Rosen.
- Applications abandoned and revived: 3. One went abandoned at the missing parts stage and two for an unpaid issue fee. All three were revived under 37 CFR 1.137(a), and all three patents carry a terminal disclaimer notice.
Method note: these are file-level counts across the 72 histories. One file can carry several grounds, so the categories overlap. The counts come from the OCR’d text of each file, and the smaller figures should be read as approximate.
The Top Ten
1. Color on a cap drawn entirely in broken lines, and the examiner’s written menu of fixes
The file: Application No. 29/805,393 (bottle, D1,157,265), filed August 26, 2021 by Conopco.
The problem: The bottle and cap were drawn in broken lines, with ornament on the body and color on the cap. The examiner rejected under 112(a) and (b): color covering the whole of an unclaimed curved surface leaves the claim with no boundary. Counsel’s argument that bottles of various shapes would fall within the patent was rejected as an attempt to broaden the claim. A final rejection, an advisory action refusing a retitled “Bottle Including a Colored Top,” and a CPA arguing Curver followed. The first action in the CPA was made final, citing In re Iknayan: “the patentability of design may not rest on color alone.”
The move: After a video interview on May 21, 2026, the examiner put written notes in the file. For the body, the ornament could stay as drawn, with the claim understood to stop at the edge of each element, “similar to ‘a stamp’,” or a dot-dash boundary could claim the spaces between. For the cap, the choices were solid lines, no color, or color kept only on the flat top with a solid or dot-dash edge.
The result: The reply colored only the top of the cap, added lines showing its planar structure, and gave the color a dash-dot-dash edge, which the patent describes as the boundary of the claimed design. Allowed.
The takeaway: Color on an unclaimed curved surface has no edge. Put it on a defined, preferably flat, surface with a stated boundary, and when an examiner offers options in an interview, ask for them in writing.
2. A narrower claim in a continuation is refused as a “claim shift,” and a CPA gets it allowed
The file: Application No. 29/891,100 (battery charger, D1,157,313), filed May 1, 2023 by The Noco Company as a continuation of the application that became D988,990.
The problem: The continuation claimed the same design as its parent. The examiner rejected under 35 USC 171 for same-design double patenting, which a terminal disclaimer cannot cure.
The move: Counsel filed new drawings claiming only the upper casing, with the lower portion, plugs and cables in broken lines. The final rejection of January 28, 2026 refused to consider them. The examiner found the new claim patentably distinct from the whole charger as filed, said it would add search burden, and wrote that “the amendment is itself a claim shift, which is not permitted by the Office. See MPEP 819.” Because the original design had received an action on the merits, it was “constructively elected by original presentation,” the new drawings were withdrawn as a non-elected invention, and the 171 rejection was made final.
The result: Counsel filed a CPA with the same drawings. The examiner established the CPA, raised nothing further, and allowed the claim.
The takeaway: In a continuation, file the scope you want from the start. If a narrower claim is refused as a shift after an action on the merits, a CPA presents it as a new application, and here that was enough. Note the examiner’s finding that the upper casing claim is patentably distinct from the full charger.
3. Withdrawn from issue more than a year after allowance, then saved by a declaration about an Amazon link’s history
The file: Application No. 29/900,536 (magnetic knife holder, D1,157,236), filed August 22, 2023 by an individual applicant.
The problem: The notice of allowance was mailed April 30, 2025, and the issue fee was paid. On June 24, 2026, the Technology Center Director withdrew the application from issue “due to unpatentability of the claim” under 37 CFR 1.313(b). The examiner then rejected under 103 over an Amazon listing for a HOSHANHO knife block in view of D482,245. The only difference was a burnt-in logo in one corner, and the examiner treated its absence as “an uninterrupted surface replacing an etched in graphic.”
The move: The inventor filed a Rule 130(a) declaration. A company the inventor authorized sold the product through the HOSHANHO store. The declaration also explained the date: the Amazon link was registered September 4, 2022, but the product sold under it then was a different one, and the claimed design was listed on March 29, 2023, within the grace period. The declaration carries the full 18 USC 1001 acknowledgment.
The result: The claim was allowed again, with a notice mailed October 1, 2026, and issued seven weeks later. The printed patent lists the reference as “announced Sep. 4, 2022.”
The takeaway: An allowed case is not safe until it issues. When an Amazon page predates the product, the seller’s own records of when the product was added to it can move the date of the reference.
4. An inventor’s trade-show reveal defeats a third party’s later Instagram post under Rule 130(b)
The file: Application No. 29/983,306 (personal watercraft, D1,157,308), filed January 9, 2025 by two individual applicants.
The problem: The first action rejected the claim under 102(a)(1) over two Instagram posts: the applicants’ own announcement of a model “Revealed at the Cannes Yachting Festival,” first available September 12, 2024, and a third party’s post of a “6-seater jetcar” from December 16, 2024.
The move: The applicants answered the first post with an inventor’s declaration that did not say it was under Rule 130(a). The examiner treated it as one anyway, with a warning: “In the future, Applicant must clearly submit an affidavit or declaration of attribution under 37 CFR 1.130(a).” The final rejection kept the third-party post and attributed the differences in creases and proportions to the “photographic nature” of the reference. After final, counsel filed a Rule 130(b) declaration showing that the design had been publicly disclosed at the festival, held September 10 to 15, 2024, before the third-party post. Counsel also argued that the photographs never showed the underside, which is claimed in solid lines.
The result: Allowed. The reasons for allowance rely on the festival post predating the third-party post. They cite 35 USC 102(b)(2), but the exception that fits a 102(a)(1) disclosure is 102(b)(1)(B), the one counsel invoked.
The takeaway: When someone else posts the design after you have shown it publicly, a Rule 130(b) declaration removes the later post without any argument about appearance. Label every declaration with the rule it is filed under.
5. A Rule 130(a) declaration without the 18 USC 1001 warning is accepted, along with remarks that still read “XXX”
The file: Application No. 29/920,522 (F bar clamp storage rack, D1,157,248), filed December 12, 2023 by an individual applicant.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 102 over a Fulton Woodworking Tools clamp rack published June 26, 2023, and under 103 over a Rockler rack in view of the same Fulton product.
The move: The reply said that Fulton is the inventor’s brand and that the inventor owns it, each “as evidenced by XXX.” The placeholder was never filled in. The inventor’s declaration says the cited reference “pertains to the Applicant’s own product,” attaches business and trademark registrations, and closes: “willful false statements may jeopardize the validity of this application or any patent issuing therefrom.” It does not mention fine, imprisonment or 18 USC 1001. Without Fulton, counsel argued, Rockler alone could not support the 103 rejection.
The result: The examiner found “reasonable proof,” withdrew both rejections, and allowed the claim.
The takeaway: Last week a declaration with nearly the same closing sentence cost another applicant a final rejection (item 5, the litter scoop). Examiners are not consistent on this point, so do not rely on leniency. Use the full 37 CFR 1.68 language, and proofread for placeholders before filing.
6. Three anticipation rejections fall to the effective filing date, one only after a final rejection
The files: Application Nos. 29/956,479 (golf ball marker, D1,157,401, On Point Ball Marker), 29/961,592 (permanent outdoor light, D1,157,448) and 30/001,239 (post cover, D1,157,442).
The problem: The golf ball marker was filed in 2024 in a chain of continuations, divisionals and CIPs, claiming the benefit of a March 15, 2019 application. It was rejected under 102(a)(1) over European and British registrations, published April 2, 2019, that the applicant said it owned.
The move: The first reply filed a statement invoking the common ownership exception of 35 USC 102(b)(2)(C). That exception reaches only 102(a)(2) art. The final rejection held that the “affidavits/declaration are intermingled within the attorney’s arguments” and that “a proper affidavit/declaration must be a separate paper signed by the inventors.” After an interview, the next reply led with the fact that both registrations were published after March 15, 2019.
The result: Allowed. In the outdoor light file, an Amazon listing from August 17, 2024 fell once the applicant filed the certified copy of a March 20, 2024 Chinese priority application. As the reply put it, “This rejection is in error once priority is perfected.” In the post cover file, the reference was posted February 17, 2025, and the examiner agreed in an interview that it came after the December 12, 2024 Chinese priority date.
The takeaway: Check the effective filing date before reaching for Rule 130 or an ownership statement. For design applications, file the certified copy early.
7. A single-reference obviousness rejection built on “reversed” features is withdrawn for lack of art showing the differences
The file: Application No. 29/991,544 (programmable logic controller, D1,157,326), filed February 28, 2025 by Siemens.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 103 over D692,840 alone. The features on the front, top, bottom and rear were arranged in reverse, and the claim added two data ports, a plain rectangular surface and a row of rectangular features. The examiner reasoned that reversing the orientation of existing features “has not resulted in a new design” and called the rest de minimis, citing In re Lamb. The same action included an obviousness-type double patenting rejection over a copending application and a 112 rejection.
The move: Counsel filed a terminal disclaimer and corrected the drawings. On the 103 rejection, counsel compared the views one by one, pointing to the plain plate beside the ports and an extra row of surface detail, and noted that the examiner had cited no second reference.
The result: Allowed. The examiner wrote that “in the absence of prior art teaching of said differences,” together with the differences on the front and back, the claimed design is distinct from the reference.
The takeaway: When a single-reference rejection calls the differences rearrangements or de minimis, ask where the record shows them. Here the missing evidence is the reason the examiner gave for withdrawing the rejection.
8. Citing the USPTO’s LKQ guidance: a primary reference read with its ceiling canopy is not the claimed pendant
The file: Application No. 29/988,230 (luminaire, D1,157,449), filed January 31, 2025 by Beta-Calco.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 103 over D870,356 in view of D809,699. The primary reference had a flat, pill-shaped housing with a light strip along the edge. The secondary reference was cited for a strip running along the entire edge, a change the examiner called a “simple substitution or addition of one known design element for another.”
The move: Counsel quoted the USPTO’s post-LKQ examination guidance: the comparison “must focus on the visual impression of the claimed design as a whole and not on selected individual pieces.” The primary reference claims the pendant together with a ceiling-mounted fixture whose shape matches it, while this claim covers the pendant alone. Pendant to pendant, the reference has flat ends with curved corners where the claim has full semicircles, and a taller profile. Counsel also showed that the secondary reference’s strip does not continue around the end.
The result: Allowed without a further action. The notice gives no reasons.
The takeaway: Read the primary reference as the whole design it claims, including parts your claim leaves out. Then check that the secondary reference actually shows the feature it is cited for.
9. Maatita, two Board decisions and added shading overcome a single-view enablement rejection
The file: Application No. 29/988,602 (article of jewelry, D1,157,286), filed February 5, 2025 by Louis Vuitton Malletier.
The problem: The circular shapes inside the circular elements patterned around the back of the piece appeared only in a single plan view, Fig. 3. The examiner rejected under 112(a) and (b) because their depth could not be determined, and suggested reducing them to broken lines.
The move: Counsel kept them in the claim. The replacement Fig. 3 added surface shading “to clarify that the relevant regions indicate flat surfaces,” and the remarks pointed to the perspective, top and bottom views, which show that the features do not extend beyond the back surface. On the law, counsel cited In re Maatita, 900 F.3d 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2018), and two Board decisions, one of them accepting a single view of a shoe sole: no rule requires a particular number of views, only enough to understand the design with reasonable certainty.
The result: “Upon further review,” the examiner withdrew the rejection and allowed the claim.
The takeaway: Before converting a single-view feature to broken lines, argue Maatita and use the other views. Shading that settles flat versus recessed can be accepted, but it must be supported by the original disclosure, and the examiner had warned about written description.
10. Boundary lines under Owens: straight connectors are fine, arbitrary curves are new matter
The file: Application No. 29/941,381 (trash can foothold, D1,157,474), filed May 9, 2024 by Findlay Machine & Tool.
The problem: The first action found the bounds of the claim unclear because broken lines ran directly into solid lines around ribbed features. The same action included a provisional obviousness-type double patenting rejection over a copending application.
The move: Counsel added dash-dot boundary lines and filed a terminal disclaimer.
The result: The examiner accepted the disclaimer but made a new final rejection under 112(a). Citing In re Owens, the examiner explained that a straight broken line connecting the ends of existing solid lines can be added, but “any broken line boundary other than a straight broken line may constitute new matter.” Where the new boundary curved, “the radii of curvatures are arbitrarily chosen.” The action included diagrams of permitted and forbidden boundaries. The applicant redrew the boundaries to follow lines already disclosed, and the claim was allowed.
The takeaway: When adding boundary lines after filing, connect existing line ends with straight lines or follow lines already shown. Do not draw a new curve.
Honorable Mentions
- Application No. 29/896,567 (can rack, EP Family): after a final rejection under 102 over a 2003 design patent and a 1995 utility patent, the applicant converted every broken line to solid lines, which overcame the art; the advisory action then found the bottom features indefinite, and they went back to broken lines.
- Application No. 29/981,963 (bottle with cap, Monday International): an influencer’s Instagram video marked as gifted by the applicant’s brand was removed with two declarations, one from the inventor at an affiliated company and one from the marketing manager who sent the sample.
- Application No. 29/989,659 (container, Cirkul): the applicant’s own Instagram reel was removed by a Rule 130(a) declaration signed by the assignee’s chief IP counsel, not the inventor.
- Application No. 30/000,782 (mobile power device, Ugreen): of three alternative 103 grounds, two fell to a declaration removing the applicant’s own listing; the third fell to an argument that the lines in both references were mold or assembly lines, supported by a photo taken from the comments section of a listing.
- Application No. 30/023,234 (folding travel bag): the reply agreed that the examiner’s findings were correct and that the Amazon reference looks the same as the claim, then removed it with evidence that the inventor had authorized the seller.
- Application No. 29/928,471 (bag, Coulter Ventures): a CPA filed after allowance to get an information disclosure statement considered, but the examiner lined out non-patent references filed without legible copies.
- Application No. 29/873,878 (display screen, HES IP Holdings): two views showing icons as they appear in the three-dimensional space of an environment were rejected as unclear in purpose and cancelled.
- Application No. 29/905,511 (knife holder): the application went abandoned before examination because a micro entity certification was filed without the surcharge the notice required; two petitions were dismissed before it was revived with a terminal disclaimer.
Enforcement Watch
- A boundary around color. D1,157,265 claims color only on the top of the cap, inside a dash-dot-dash boundary. The file also holds counsel’s earlier statement that bottles of various shapes would fall within the patent, and the examiner’s rejection of that reading as an attempt to broaden.
- A finding of distinctness. In D1,157,313, the examiner found the upper casing claim patentably distinct from the full charger as originally filed, which was the same design claimed in the parent, D988,990. The patent issued without a terminal disclaimer.
- A reference date printed on the face. D1,157,236 lists its own seller’s reference as “announced Sep. 4, 2022,” earlier than the inventor’s sworn listing date. The patent rests on the inventor’s sworn explanation that the claimed product was not listed until March 29, 2023.
- Grace period disclosures. D1,157,308 rests on a public reveal at a September 2024 festival, four months before filing. D1,157,263, D1,157,232, D1,157,248 and others rest on sworn attribution of the applicant’s own listings and posts. Those dates matter for foreign filings and for any later public use or on-sale question.
- A declaration that may be tested. The attribution declaration in D1,157,248 omits the 18 USC 1001 acknowledgment. An accused infringer may ask whether it met 37 CFR 1.68.
- Priority as the only defense. D1,157,401, D1,157,448 and D1,157,442 each survived art that postdates their priority dates. A challenge to the priority chain or the foreign priority claim would bring that art back.
- An admission of sameness. In the file for D1,157,187, the applicant agreed that the Amazon product cited against it looks the same as the claim. That is useful for marking and for identifying the commercial embodiment.
- Term. D1,157,268 and D1,157,269 are tied to each other by terminal disclaimers. D1,157,184, D1,157,326, D1,157,336 and D1,157,474 carry disclaimers over related applications, and D1,157,350 carries disclaimers for double patenting and for its revival. D1,157,235 and D1,157,448 carry disclaimers from their revivals.
What to Take From the Week
- Never claim color or ornament on a surface you have drawn in broken lines without giving it a boundary. A flat surface with a stated edge is what the examiner accepted.
- In a continuation, file the claim scope you want at the outset. If a narrower claim is refused as a shift, a CPA can present it.
- Read Rule 130 declarations as if a court will. Include the full 37 CFR 1.68 language, say which subsection the declaration is filed under, and file it as a separate paper signed by the declarant.
- When a stranger’s post follows your own public disclosure, use Rule 130(b).
- Check the effective filing date, including continuity and foreign priority, before arguing anything else. File certified priority copies early.
- Answer a single-reference obviousness rejection by asking what in the record shows the differences.
- Read the whole primary reference, including parts your claim omits.
- Argue Maatita before converting a single-view feature to broken lines.
- Add boundary lines only as straight connectors between existing line ends or along lines already shown.
- Compare replacement drawings with the originals before filing, and file any information disclosure statement before the issue fee is paid.