File wrapper citations in this article link to the documents in ProSearch. A free Design Patent Pro account is all that is needed to open them.
This week’s batch is the 69 design patents that issued on November 10, 2026 after at least one rejection. Most followed the familiar path from a drawing rejection to replacement sheets to allowance. Ten files are worth keeping.
The one to read first is an Ishi Studios undergarment drawn as if worn by an invisible wearer. The examiner reasoned that stretch fabric takes the shape of whatever is inside it, so the drawn contours could not set the design apart from the prior art. The applicant got past that only through a continued prosecution application, and then won by showing that the examiner had read a reference from the wrong side. Also this week: one sentence of description that cured a final 112 rejection, an obviousness rejection built on two Amazon listings withdrawn after an argument resting only on PTAB authority, a see-through mesh that had to be drawn as see-through, a Rule 130 declaration that failed for want of the statutory warning, and three examiners who disagreed about whether stippling should be described at all.
The Week in Numbers
- 69 prosecution histories: 39 in the 29 series, 27 in the 30 series and 3 Hague designations in the 35 series. Median time from filing to issue: about 21 months. The range ran from about 8 months (a mouth tape filed March 9, 2026) to just over 5 years.
- How they got there: 57 were allowed without a final rejection or an Ex parte Quayle action. 6 received a final rejection and 7 a Quayle action (one file received both). 7 had a restriction requirement. 1 drew an advisory action. 2 applicants filed a continued prosecution application (CPA).
- Rejections by ground: 35 USC 112 in about 52 files. 102 in 17. 103 in 2. Obviousness-type double patenting in 3, all cured by terminal disclaimer, and one same-design rejection under 35 USC 171, withdrawn on argument. One more 171 rejection, for a graphical user interface, was cured by amending the title and claim to name the display panel.
- Rule 130 declarations in 15 files, all of them answering the applicant’s own listing or an authorized seller’s. The other two 102 rejections were overcome by argument alone. Amazon listings supplied the cited art in at least 11 files. No Rule 132 declarations. Interviews or examiner calls in about 9 files. No notices of appeal.
- LKQ v. GM was cited in no file. Two rejections still quoted the “so related” test of In re Glavas and In re Rosen: one under 103 and one for obviousness-type double patenting.
- Applications abandoned and restored: 2. One was revived under 37 CFR 1.137(a) and its printed patent carries a terminal disclaimer notice. The other had its holding of abandonment withdrawn under 37 CFR 1.181, and its patent carries no disclaimer.
Method note: these are file-level counts across the 69 histories. One file can carry several grounds, so the categories overlap. The counts come from the OCR’d text of each file, and the smaller figures should be read as approximate.
The Top Ten
1. An “invisible wearer” rejection for stretch fabric, a CPA, and a reference read from the wrong side
The file: Application No. 29/849,955 (male seamless undergarment, D1,156,802), a continuation filed August 16, 2022 by Ishi Studios.
The problem: The drawings show the garment shaped as if worn. In a final rejection under 103, the examiner refused to give those contours weight, reasoning that “such garments take the shape of whatever is put inside them” and that a prior art garment placed on a mannequin shaped like the invisible “wearer” in the drawings would look the same. The examiner added that nothing in the original disclosure showed the contours without a wearer.
The move: Counsel called that approach “impermissible hindsight reconstruction” and filed a CPA under 37 CFR 1.53(d) with corrected drawings. The examiner withdrew those rejections, citing the amended drawings and an updated search rather than the argument, but rejected again over a seamless men’s underwear listing in view of D864,523 for the two seams beside the pouch. Counsel showed that the figure relied on was a rear view of the secondary reference, that its front seams form a V while the claimed lines form a U, and that nothing suggested placing them outside the pouch.
The result: The examiner found the arguments sufficient and allowed the claim. The reasons for allowance name the widely spaced U-shaped lines, the seamless rear and the rounded pouch.
The takeaway: For soft goods drawn on a phantom body, expect contour alone to be discounted, and give the claim lines and edges that do not depend on a wearer. Always check which view of a reference the examiner is reading.
2. One sentence of description, filed after final, settles whether a heart is flush or recessed
The file: Application No. 29/888,713 (ring, D1,156,912), filed April 4, 2023.
The problem: After an interview and a set of replacement drawings, the examiner made final a 112(a) and (b) rejection on April 2, 2026. The heart shapes in Figs. 2 and 5 “may be flush with the surrounding edges or may be heart-shaped recessed surfaces,” and the drawings did not say which. The examiner suggested reducing the heart lines to broken lines.
The move: In a reply under 37 CFR 1.116, counsel changed no drawings. The amendment added one sentence after the figure descriptions: “The heart shape indicated in Figures 2 and 5 is flush with the surrounding edges.”
The result: The examiner entered the amendment, found that the corrections overcame the rejection, and allowed the claim. The sentence is printed on the patent.
The takeaway: When the drawings support two readings and redrawing risks new matter, a short descriptive statement that picks the reading already shown can keep the feature in the claim instead of disclaiming it. Expect that statement to define scope later.
3. An obviousness rejection built on two Amazon “Date First Available” entries is withdrawn after a burden argument alone
The file: Application No. 29/929,162 (hose connector for medical use, D1,157,093), filed February 20, 2024 by Koninklijke Philips.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 103 over one Amazon listing for a push-to-connect fitting in view of another. Both pages were captured on June 26, 2025. The dates given for them, July 1, 2019 and July 9, 2020, were the “Date First Available” entries on those captures. The rejection relied on the “so related” language of Rosen and Glavas.
The move: Counsel did not argue the designs and filed no declaration. The response argued only that the Office had not shown either listing was prior art, citing Vectair Systems v. Fresh Products (IPR2024-00824, Paper 9, Nov. 12, 2024), Next Step Group v. Deckers Outdoor (IPR2024-00525, Aug. 6, 2024) and two ex parte appeal decisions. Listings and their photographs change over time, so a “first available” date does not show when the pictured design was published.
The result: The notice of allowability gives no reasons. It states only that the amendment, which changed nothing but the specification, “overcomes the objection to the specification and the 35 USC 103 Rejection.” Allowed.
The takeaway: Last week, one applicant beat an Amazon date with a Rule 132 declaration and another by showing that Amazon recycles product numbers. Here, when the examiner offered nothing beyond the “Date First Available” line, the burden argument alone was enough. Keep these PTAB citations in the response template.
4. A see-through mesh must be drawn as see-through
The file: Application No. 30/005,319 (garment, D1,156,801), filed May 25, 2025 by Lululemon Athletica Canada.
The problem: The specification gave the crosshatching on the back of the garment three meanings in three “embodiments”: a see-through mesh, a contrast in appearance only, and no part of the claim. The examiner rejected under 112: only one embodiment was shown, the meanings contradicted each other, and the third would disclaim solid lines. For transparency, the examiner pointed to MPEP 1503.02 and explained that “the underlying surface (the inside of the garment at the opposite side) would be expected to be at least partially visible.” The examiner also noted that alternative statements of this kind may be filed with an application to provide antecedent basis for a later amendment.
The move: Counsel kept the mesh description, cancelled the other two, and redrew Figs. 2 and 6 to show the parts of the front of the garment that would be visible through the mesh.
The result: Allowed. The examiner distinguished a 2018 Instagram post showing a similar mesh racerback on proportions alone: a wider racerback, a lower neckline and a much wider cutout.
The takeaway: If a surface is transparent, draw what lies behind it. Alternative-meaning statements can preserve options at filing, but expect to choose one before allowance.
5. A strong Rule 130(a) declaration fails for want of the 18 USC 1001 warning
The file: Application No. 29/932,874 (litter scoop, D1,157,145), filed March 15, 2024 by Peck Rock Associates.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 102 over the applicant’s own Amazon listing, first available February 24, 2024, three weeks before filing. The examiner also objected to the original title, “Improved Litter Scoop,” because “improved” is a marketing term.
The move: The inventor’s first declaration did the substantive work. She stated that she owns and operates the seller account, that everything posted under it was created or directed by her, and that the cited page is her own listing, and she attached it as an exhibit. But it closed with this: “I am aware that willful false statements are punishable and may jeopardize the validity of any patent issuing from the Application.”
The result: The examiner found the facts sufficient but made the rejection final because the declaration did not acknowledge that willful false statements are punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both, under 18 USC 1001. The inventor signed a new declaration with the full language, and the rejection was withdrawn.
The takeaway: Include the full 37 CFR 1.68 acknowledgment: fine or imprisonment, 18 USC 1001, and jeopardy to validity. Copying it verbatim is the safe course. A paraphrase here cost a final rejection and another round.
6. Describe the stippling, or delete the description? Three examiners, three answers
The files: Application Nos. 29/921,374 (bra, D1,156,800, Nike), 29/964,097 (aerosol generating device, D1,157,132, Philip Morris Products) and 29/970,083 (plant mat, D1,156,916, Fiskars).
The problem: Nike’s examiner objected that the specification needed a statement that the stippling shows contour and not a surface material, and supplied one. Philip Morris’s examiner objected to almost the same sentence already in its specification, “The stippling shadings show contours and neither ornamentation, nor coloration, nor surface finishing,” and required its removal. Fiskars’s examiner struck a statement that conventional shading forms no part of the claimed design, explaining that “shading does form a part of the claim” and that removing shading can be new matter.
The move: Nike amended nothing. In an interview, counsel argued that no MPEP provision requires a description of stippling, and in the same call explained that a feature the examiner read as a pass-through slit was a closed pocket. Philip Morris and Fiskars deleted their statements.
The result: Nike’s examiner agreed on both points and allowed the claim without amendment. Philip Morris and Fiskars were allowed after deleting the statements and amending their drawings for other reasons. In a fourth file, 29/985,974 (loudspeaker, D1,156,975), Harman deleted a similar shading statement and a 47-figure appendix.
The takeaway: No rule requires a shading statement, and examiners often strike one. Never say that shading forms no part of the claim. If an examiner insists on a statement, raise it in an interview.
7. An advisory action asks for a holistic fix, and a CPA delivers it in four days
The file: Application No. 29/939,297 (retractable cutter, D1,156,877), filed April 25, 2024 by an individual applicant.
The problem: The first action listed many drawing defects: profiles that did not match, dotted lines used to separate surfaces, alphanumeric section views, and shade lines running across contours. The final rejection added that the shade lines “create a cartoonish appearance.” An after-final amendment answered each listed point. The advisory action said the applicant was “only addressing the exact issues identified by the examiner,” when the problems ran across several views.
The move: Because RCEs are not available in design applications, counsel filed a CPA with a new set of drawings.
The result: Four days later the examiner allowed the claim. The examiner wrote that “the surface shading is less than optimal,” but four perspective views supplied enough information. An examiner’s amendment also removed the “second embodiment” label from two views that show the blade and switch in alternate positions, because the design itself does not change.
The takeaway: When the list of drawing defects is long, treat it as a sample and redraw the whole set. In a design case, the CPA is the tool for one more round, and it can be fast.
8. A 535-figure catalog filing is regrouped on traversal, then cleared by a company officer’s declaration
The file: Application No. 29/852,413 (lighting fixture, D1,157,122), filed September 7, 2022 by Hinkley Lighting, with a 2019 benefit date.
The problem: The application disclosed 72 embodiments of more than twenty fixtures in 535 figures, some of them photographs of textured glass. The examiner restricted it into more than fifty groups, observing that it “appears to be an assortment of products from the seller’s catalog.” After an election with traverse, the examiner rejected the elected group under 102 over Hinkley’s own fixture on Amazon, first available June 28, 2018, less than a year before the benefit date.
The move: The traversal had argued that similar embodiments were split across groups, and the examiner joined two more embodiments into the elected group, for four in all. To answer the 102 rejection, counsel filed a Rule 130(a) declaration from the applicant’s general counsel and vice president, not the inventor, stating that the inventor designed the fixture for Hinkley before Hinkley put it on sale. Seven joint inventors were deleted to match the elected group.
The result: The examiner found that the design in the reference “was obtained directly or indirectly from the inventor” and allowed four embodiments on 19 sheets.
The takeaway: A traversal can enlarge the elected group when near-identical variants are split. A company officer with knowledge of the facts can sign the attribution declaration, although in the litter scoop file the examiner said the inventor should.
9. Swearing behind your own listing with an earlier release date for the same Amazon product
The file: Application No. 29/921,347 (lifting device for agricultural machines, D1,157,016), filed December 15, 2023 by Shanghai Yinta.
The problem: The examiner rejected the claim under 102 over an Amazon Canada page for the applicant’s own lift, dated February 15, 2023.
The move: Instead of attributing that page, the inventor filed a declaration under Rule 130(b) proving an earlier one. The Amazon.com seller record for the same product number showed an “Offering Release Date” of January 17, 2023, inside the grace period, and the response invoked 35 USC 102(b)(1)(B), which removes a later disclosure of subject matter the inventor had already disclosed. Attachments traced the applicant’s change of name and the Hong Kong affiliate that owns the brand shown in the listing.
The result: The examiner found the declaration sufficient and allowed the claim. In 30/004,452 (shoe cabinet, D1,156,856), a Rule 130(a) affidavit relied on the inventor’s own earlier offers through two stores in November 2024, and the examiner withdrew the rejection because “the inventor’s own disclosure predates the cited reference.”
The takeaway: When the cited page is a regional copy or a reseller’s listing, the inventor’s earliest disclosure can be the better anchor. Here one examiner accepted backend seller records as that evidence, with the corporate chain documented.
10. Deleting lines that were supposed to become broken lines is new matter
The file: Application No. 30/005,498 (pitter, D1,156,870), filed May 27, 2025.
The problem: The first action found inconsistencies between views and poor line quality. The response said it placed the identified areas in broken lines and improved the lines.
The move: This one is a cautionary tale. In the replacement Figs. 2, 3 and 6, several of those features were not converted. They were gone.
The result: The examiner issued a Quayle action objecting under 35 USC 132 and 37 CFR 1.121, explaining that “completely removing broken lines is objectionable new matter.” A surface in Fig. 9 had also been left claimed between two broken-line borders. The applicant restored the features in broken lines and fixed Fig. 9, and the claim was allowed.
The takeaway: Convert, do not erase. Before filing replacement sheets, compare them with the originals line by line, especially when the redraw was also meant to improve line quality.
Honorable Mentions
- Application No. 29/986,009 (baby car seat cover): the 102 reference was the applicant’s own cover, on sale since July 2022 and outside the grace period, and the applicant won on argument alone by pointing to side vents and tapered side panels the examiner’s single image did not show.
- Application Nos. 29/945,003 and 29/945,004 (lamps): merging lines were cured by adding enlarged views made from the original drawings, at the examiner’s suggestion; a Quayle action then required consecutive figure numbers (3A and 3B became 3 and 4) and a description of the dot-dash boundary lines.
- Application No. 29/866,473 (display panel with graphical user interface for an intravascular ultrasound system): a final 112(a) rejection because the enlarged view used a different font and different text than the figure it enlarged; two of the applicant’s responses were captioned with another application’s number.
- Application No. 29/810,878 (night light base): the issue fee transmittal was faxed in December 2024, the Office had no record of it, and the application went abandoned; a petition under 37 CFR 1.181 with a copy and the fax header got the holding withdrawn.
- Application No. 29/942,264 (beverage dispensing station): after a missed issue fee, the first revival petition was dismissed because it was signed in the inventor’s other name rather than the name of record.
- Application No. 29/967,698 (faucet): a provisional same-design rejection under 35 USC 171 over a sibling application was withdrawn on the argument that the two faucets are different designs; a final rejection for pixelated lines came with the examiner’s advice to file vector art or a lossless format.
- Application No. 29/909,321 (pants decoration): a 102 rejection was withdrawn on argument that the claimed stripes taper on the front and protrude from the fabric, while the reference’s stripes are flush.
- Application No. 35/523,252 (perfume bottle, Fendi): the examiner asked that the trademark statement say whether the trademarked ornament, shown in broken lines, is claimed or not.
Enforcement Watch
- Scope tied to lines, not contour. The reasons for allowance in D1,156,802 rest on the U-shaped lines, the seamless rear and the rounded pouch, and the record contains the examiner’s view that the contours of a stretch garment cannot distinguish it. Expect an accused infringer to argue that contour adds little to the claim.
- A flush heart. D1,156,912 states on its face that the heart shape is flush with the surrounding edges. A ring with a recessed heart has a ready argument.
- Mesh with no pattern. D1,156,801 says the crosshatching shows mesh without any particular pattern, while the examiner read the windowpane grid as a pattern. The allowance rests on proportions: a wider racerback, lower neckline and wider cutout than the 2018 reference.
- Proportions in the reasons for allowance. D1,157,107 (mouth tape, Application No. 30/051,246) was allowed over the closest reference because of a rectangular opening on a shorter square substrate and sharp corners. A rounded or oval version will rely on that statement.
- Your own product as prior art. In D1,156,853, the applicant’s 2022 cover is prior art, and the claim stands on the vents and tapered panels argued to distinguish it.
- Sworn sale and listing dates. D1,157,122, D1,157,145, D1,157,016 and D1,156,856 each rest on sworn statements about when and where the design was first offered or listed. Those dates matter for foreign filings and for any later public use or on-sale question.
- Term. D1,157,120 and D1,157,121 are tied by terminal disclaimers, as is D1,156,947. D1,156,861 carries a terminal disclaimer from its revival. D1,157,118 was restored by withdrawing the holding of abandonment and carries none.
- Function in the file. The specification as filed for D1,156,803 described the claimed stripes as seam-sealing tape for bed-wetting and incontinence garments. That text is not printed on the patent, but it is in the file, and an accused infringer will find it for a functionality argument.
What to Take From the Week
- Give soft goods claim lines that do not depend on a wearer, and check which view of a reference the examiner relies on.
- Before converting a disputed feature to broken lines, ask whether one sentence of description can choose the reading the drawings already show.
- When an Amazon reference has nothing behind it but “Date First Available,” put the Office to its proof before reaching for a declaration.
- Copy the full 18 USC 1001 acknowledgment into every declaration. Paraphrase invites a final rejection.
- Do not describe shading or stippling unless an examiner insists, and never say it forms no part of the claim.
- Draw transparency so the viewer can see through it.
- Answer a long list of drawing defects with a complete redraw, and use a CPA when one more round is needed.
- Convert, do not erase, and compare replacement sheets with the originals before filing.
- When an issue fee or reply goes by fax or mail, keep the transmission record. It is the difference between a 1.181 petition and a revival with a terminal disclaimer.